Ultimate Chicago Bears Draft Scenario - Running Back
So we are now down to it. There won't be much more in the way of hard news, unless Miami manages to sign somebody. It will all be speculation and unabashed rumor. So in the next 2-3 days I am presenting you with 5 different scenarios for the Bears draft and would like you to select the one that best fits what you'd like to see the Bears do. Each draft is through the first 3 rounds and put together by a WCG reader or favorite. I plan to have them all posted within 2-3 days, then I'll throw up a recap post and a poll.
The first scenario is the running back in the first round plan. This one is submitted by Chad.
tomScenario 1: Running back first
Round 1: Rashard Mendenhall, Running Back, University of Illinois
The Chicago Bears are known for two things, defense and running backs. The Bears have a long history of great running backs dating back to the early 1900’s when the NFL’s first superstar Red Grange scampered from Champaign to Chicago. The tradition carried on to the electric Gayle Sayers who mystified opposing defenses and thrilled fans. Then of course there was a man know as Sweetness. Walter Payton, while never having blazing speed, dominated the league with an incredible combination of power and moves. He would give opposing equipment managers fits because of the all the cleats that were left in the turf from hapless linebackers who where juked out of their shoes. He was also and gentleman and the face of the Chicago Bears.
But once Payton retired, the Bears haven’t found their franchise back. Neal Anderson, who took over for Payton did a nice job but was never a superstar. Nor could he come close to comparing to #34 in the hearts and minds of Bear fans. And it only went down from there. NFL busts Rashaan Slaam to Curtis Enis to Anthony Thomas to finally, our current scourge, Cedric Benson have haunted, no wait taunted, Bears fans who dream of one day getting that one guy who is deserving to play for the team of Grange, Sayers and Payton. And that day is here…
Rashard Mendenall didn’t exactly come out of nowhere but it sure seems like it. Coming out of Niles West high school he was a 5 star recruit and one of the top running back prospects in the country. For some reason (and thank God he did!) he decided to sign with Illinois and new head coach Ron Zook.
He didn’t start off with a strong freshman campaign, carrying the ball only 48 times for 218 yards. His sophomore year, he split time with current New Orleans Saint, Pierre Thomas. There he carried 78 time for 640 yards and 5 tds. But it was his junior season where he busted out. He tallied 1681 yards rushing and 17 tds. His impressive performance in the Rose Bowl was the only bright spot in an otherwise dreary game. He stood out so much that USC coach Pete Carroll said that he was the best running back that they had seen all year. And that included Jonathon Stewart, one of the top regarded running backs in all of college football.
Mendenhall used the national stage of the Rose Bowl for his coming out party but it wasn’t’ until he got to the NFL scouting combine where his draft status when from second round to second running back overall. He dazzled with his speed (4.45) and strength (26 reps).
Mendenhall has all the makings of a real franchise back and the Bears know it. And, unlike Cedric Benson, Mendenhall has carried the ball relatively much fewer times, leading people to believe that it could mean less risk of injury.
Round 2: Duane Brown OT Virginia Tech
0 recs |
13 comments
Comments
I'd like ot point out...
...that as much as I don’t want the Bears to draft him, I do recognize Mendenhall has great potential. I just don’t think the Bears will have enough around him for him to be able to make an impact for 3-4 years.
And they’re in bad territory if they aren’t drafting a QB in the first three rounds. I think this is one of those rare years that starting-caliber QB’s fall in the draft and can be available at a cheaper cost.
Let us prepare for glory! --Michael Redd
by tyger1147 on Apr 21, 2008 9:23 AM CDT reply actions 0 recs
I agree to a point...
in that, this would be a failed draft if after 3 rounds (assuming they make no trades) they don’t have a RB, OL, and QB to show for it. WIth the fourth pick I could see a WR, SS, DT or even another OL depending on where the value is.
I like the Mendenhall pick, and of course I’m a little biased, but it makes sense. Taking anyone in the first is a gamble. Why not gamble on a potential super star? Yeah, the lineman could be a home-run as well, but no tackle they draft would necessarily be expected to start right away anyway. If there are players at a skill position that JA and Co. really like then they need to take them.
For example, if they take Rashard in the first and they feel they then have a real chance at getting Brohm or Flacco but they will have to trade up to do so causing them to possibly push drafting a OL to third, then I think they have to do it. Whether we like it or not, they are building for ‘09 and you can always find OL in FA or the draft next year.
by illini on Apr 21, 2008 11:35 AM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
Let me pose this question
is something like this
Round 1: Chris Wiliams
Round 2: Matt Forte
a significantly better option than this:
Round 1: Rashard Mendenhall
Round 2: Anthony Collins
The big problem is so many of the second teir backs and QBs are so unpredictable as far as draft position we could get hosed somewhere. We either wait and take a back or a QB in the third, but have no idea who will be around.
Being Who You Thought We Were Since 2005!
by Adam T on Apr 21, 2008 9:30 AM CDT reply actions 0 recs
this is close
to ultimate as far as hometown kid drafts go.
i think the big question, like tyger, wcg and others have mentioned, is 2 years from now what gives us the best chance to win, #14 tackle this year or a #14 rb some think could be a superstar?
if you left this draft with: mendenhall, brohm (flacco), OT, etc. i think it would be hard to be too upset if you are thinking 09, that would of course mean you have to spend some cash next year on an OT, but you may have a pretty good looking team in 09. of course, not upgrading the line serioulsy screws grossman, orton and benson since their big proving years will be a struggle.
is otah the last of the 3 ot that people think can start?
by mike b on Apr 21, 2008 9:55 AM CDT reply actions 0 recs
Hard to say
Maybe on a good line, but it they have to beat out our guards it might be easier to get in.
Being Who You Thought We Were Since 2005!
by Adam T on Apr 21, 2008 10:08 AM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
I think
the league has shown us that you need a strong offensive line to have a running game, and if you do, it doesn’t matter that much who your running back is (unless he’s Adrian Peterson).
I would have much preferred the Bears addressed the line to some extent through free agency so they wouldn’t be forced to take a need in the first.
However, check this nugget out from SI, courtesy of rotoworld:
If Matt Ryan falls to the sixth or seventh pick, SI’s Peter King expects Detroit, Carolina, and Chicago all to inquire about trading up.
The Bears make a lot of sense. The Lions must not believe in Drew Stanton much if this were true. While Carolina would have to think hard about Ryan at 13, it would surprise us for them to trade up for Ryan after Matt Moore’s impressive starts last year.
Sure, it’s just idle speculation. But isn’t that what this week is all about?
DEJESUS!!!
by tomas21 on Apr 21, 2008 10:29 AM CDT reply actions 0 recs
It is great for posting
but Peter King ‘expects’ it because he probably deems the Bears biggest need to be QB.
Being Who You Thought We Were Since 2005!
by Adam T on Apr 21, 2008 11:22 AM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
he'd be right
I wouldn’t mind the Bears trading up for either McFadden or Ryan, maybe Benson or Grossman sweeten the deal… (never gonna happen). QB is the Bears biggest need. Grossman is garbage. I think orton is decent but i hope we darft a qb in the 2nd or 3rd round. OL or RB Bears are still gonna call HB dive for 0-1 yard every play anyway… only a star QB or RB might break that mold, but not an OL.
by 234L on Apr 21, 2008 1:30 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
why
does the draft start so late this year?
by mike b on Apr 21, 2008 12:27 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
They did it to...
start driving the effort of making the first round a prime-time event leaving the last six for Sunday.
The first step was to shorten the first two rounds and to start a little later.
The next step is to start the first round at roughly 6 or 7 pm eastern so it can be done around midnight. They would then do the rest of the draft Sunday morning/afternoon.
They want to make the draft a prime-time event like the NBA does.
by illini on Apr 21, 2008 12:33 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
chad
I actually think shard was a ron turner recruit. zook and shard both went to illinois in 2005 and zook didnt start recruiting till late, but I could be wrong. But I heard shard cwent to illinois cause his brother was going there, I forget his name, mostly because everyone just refers to him as reshards brother.
-leopoldjones
by leopoldjones on Apr 21, 2008 3:23 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
shaun alexander released
hell no we don’t want him.
by mike b on Apr 22, 2008 7:20 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
SHOOOOOOT!
Alexander is a better back all old and broken then Benson will ever be. Still dont want him though.
by SuperBowlXX on Apr 23, 2008 8:32 AM CDT reply actions 0 recs

by 


















