Windy City Gridiron: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
New Blog: Sounder At Heart for Seattle Sounders Fans!

Rookie Running Back Comparison

Seven running backs were selected in first two rounds of this past draft.  Here is a look at how their numbers compare.

 

Player Attempts Yards TDs Rec Yards TDs
(order based on drafted position)
Darren McFAdden 44 252 1 5 26 0
Jonathan Stewart 31 145 3 0 0 0
Felix Jones 18 148 2 1 3 0
Rashard Mendedhall 10 28 0 1 11 0
Chris Johnson 50 276 0 7 51 1
Matt Forte 73 304 1 13 105 1
Ray Rice 27 85 0 3 19 0

Based on these numbers we can re rank them like this:

1) Matt Forte
2) Chris Johnson
3) Jonathan Stewart
4) Felix Jones
5)Darren McFadden
6) Rashard Mendenhall
7) Ray Rice

 

Star-divide

Obviously, Mendenhall and Rice are not even in the conversation currently. There is room to debate the order of the rest. It would be easy for someone to call me a homer at this point, but I think there is sufficient evidence to back the statement that Forte is the most important rookie back if not the best so far this year, granted we are 3 games in. Forte is the only one of the group who is their team's starting back, though cases could be made that Johnson and Stewart should be. Forte is also the only back  that has any involvement in the pass game. And until the Bears pass game can show they are a threat opposing team's defenses will key in on him.

1. Matt Forte: When it comes to running the football, he is indisputably "the man" in Chicago, a heady experience for any NFL rookie. But Forte is showing the maturity to pull it off. In three starts, no team has been able to hold him to less than 89 yards by the end of the game. And he's established himself as a player who has to be accounted for in the passing game with 13 catches already. No rookie running back is carrying the ball more often for his team than Forte, and he's getting good results despite a lackluster Bears passing attack that is doing little to take pressure off the running game.

The article attached has the list like this:  Forte, Johnson, McFadden, Stewart, Jones, Rice and Mendenhall.

I did have to pause when deciding between Johnson and Stewart for 2 and 3. Stewart is by far the strongest runner while Johnson is the fastest, but you can't look past Johnson's numbers. You could also make a case for Jones on the grounds that he isn't making the numbers because he is stuck behind Marion Barber III.  One could also plead the case of McFadden as he is stuck in the hell hole that is Oakland, but that's life in the NFL.

I don't know where they will end up by year's end and we will revisit this topic a few times before.

Your turn.  Rank em. 

 

Other News and Notes:

Devin Hester is a game time decision again this week.   While we all agree that you can't replace Hester, the Bears have been able to admirably replace him with a few different fill ins.

Don't forget to adjust your FF rosters.  This is the first round of bye weeks.  Teams on BYE are: Detroit, Indianapolis, Miami, New England, NY Giants and Seattle.

Tommie Harris missed practice on Friday.  Missing practice on Friday is cutting it a little close for being able to play on Sunday.

 

 

0 recs  |  Comment 11 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Rankings?

What are you ranking on?

McFadden has the 3rd most total yards and the second best ypc, while arguably playing on the worst team.

FWIW… Forte is 5th in ypc.

I would probably say something like this:
Forte – but more for the role he is playing than that he is that much better
McFadden
Johnson
Stewart
Jones
Mendenhall/Rice

by big_lowitzki on Sep 26, 2008 2:15 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

AND...

McFadden is averaged 5.7 yards per carry!!.

That is really good.

by big_lowitzki on Sep 26, 2008 2:27 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

That is why I mentioned it being a rankings so far as most important

and not just out right best.

Being Who You Thought We Were Since 2005!

by Adam T on Sep 26, 2008 4:00 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

how bout quit hattin

forte is the best we have had scince neil andreson and you wannna shit on him…..nice

by SuperBowlXX on Sep 26, 2008 3:12 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Who's....

“hattin?” And who is shitting on Forte?

by big_lowitzki on Sep 26, 2008 4:03 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Can we stop shi*** all together?

thank you.

Being Who You Thought We Were Since 2005!

by Adam T on Sep 26, 2008 4:27 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

what?

Maybe other teams haven’t had the need to put their rookie RBs into a big role yet… It’s almost too easy to call you a homer, that is correct. Not hating on Forte, but to say he is the best of the bunch so far best on playing time is well………HOMERISH!

by Joe_D on Sep 26, 2008 3:36 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Maybe "best" doesn't force Forte to the top

But it’s hard to argue that someone else has done more for their team.

He has rushed for more yards (albeit on more carries).
He has more than double the receiving yards of #2.
He’s the only one to have scored in both the running and passing game.

Is he “better” than the rest? Time will tell.
To this point, has he meant more to his team and achieved more than the others? No doubt.

--Torch

by torch on Sep 26, 2008 5:10 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Like I said

other teams have not needed to rely on their rook so much. Oak had Fargas, Dallas has Barber, PIT has Willie Parker…

Forte deserves some praise but to say he’s better or more valuable than the rest is homer talk at this point in the season.

by Joe_D on Sep 27, 2008 1:24 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

They're all pretty good.

It’s a nice rookie RB class.

Where’s Steve Slaton on that list?

Haven’t seen McFadden yet. Saw Felix Jones… wow: electric. Saw Stewart run over us: equally impressive. And Chris Johnson is fastest back in the league.

I'm not going to even bother trying to update this sig everyday anymore... that's what the standings column on ESPN is for.
Updated on May 25, 2008

by SackMan on Sep 27, 2008 12:50 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Tier 1
1) McFadden – I do plead the case that he’s stuck in the crapfest that is Oakland
2) Forte – Has been much better than I thought he would be.

Tier 2
3) Chris Johnson
4) Jonathan Stewart
5) Felix Jones

Tier 3
6) Steve Slaton
7) Ray Rice
8) Rashard Mendenhall – Remember when everyone here wanted to draft him? Yeah, let’s keep whitewashing that.

Insert clever and witty remark slash pun here!

UMD 8/04 - 5/08: Go Terps!

by ES46NE10 on Sep 28, 2008 5:24 AM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome Grabowskis, to SB Nation's blog about everything Chicago Bears.

Community Guidelines
Start posting about the Bears »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Lightbulb_small
Why The Defense Has Collapsed
Bears_small
Hang in there, Bears!

Recent FanPosts

Small
Lovie Smith iz Stoopid and Fire Him We Should
Throwdpeterson_small
RePoll: Iglesias or Harvin?
Blake_again_small
Let's Face The Facts............All Day Long.....................
610x_small
My keys to victory over Cardinals
Small
2010 O-Line Help in Draft? Unlikely
Medium_matt-forte_small
An interesting video!
Jimmcmahon_small
Olin Kreutz is one of the dirtiest players in the NFL
Andrew602_avatar_small
Ask Revenge of the Birds
Bears2_small
Key Player to keep an eye on: Dominique Rodgers-Comartie
Devin-hester_small
Photshop contest

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Latest NFL Headlines from SB Nation

SPONSORS


General Manager/ Head Coach

Windycity_small Adam T

Les-miles-bears-2_small Dane Noble

Assistant Head Coach

Briggsie_small ChiFan13

Position Coaches

Evalltheway_small SackMan

Leelee_n_laylor_bff wiltfongjr