Rules On Hiring NFL Coaches
With my ongoing series on possible replacements (if he's fired) for Ron Turner to coordinate the Bears offense under way, (click here for Charlie Weis and here for Mike Martz) I thought I'd throw out some hiring rules for coaches in the NFL. We are all aware of the Rooney Rule in regards to hiring Head Coaches or senior football operations positions, but there are some restrictions in hiring other members of your staff as well.
The only possible coaches that can be hired with no delay are the coaches that are currently unemployed. If you are looking to "steal" away a coach from another NFL team, there are restrictions that limit what you can do. It's not as cut and dry as locating a candidate, offering him more money, and hiring him. If the coach is under contract with another NFL team there are rules that teams must follow.
* You can't hire a coach away from another team if it's a lateral move. You can only hire a contracted coach away if he'll receive a promotion.
You can't hire one team's offensive coordinator to be your offensive coordinator. If the Bears wanted to steal away a team's offensive coordinator, then he could only be hired as Assistant Head Coach/Offensive Coordinator. For those of you thinking the Bears already have an Assistant Head Coach in Rod Marinelli so they couldn't possibly go this route, you may be mistaken. The Houston Texans currently have two coaches on staff with the Assistant Head Coach title. I'm not sure how many you can have, but apparently two is allowed.
If the Bears wanted to hire away a team's contracted quarterbacks coach to run their offense, there would be nothing that could stop them, because going from a QB Coach to an Offensive Coordinator would be a step up.
For example; If Chicago had their eye on Pittsburgh Steelers QB Coach Ken Anderson, they could hire him to be their new Offensive Coordinator, but not as a QB Coach (no lateral moves). Another example; If the Bears were interested in Kyle Shanahan, current offensive coordinator of the Houston Texans, they wouldn't be able to hire him as their new OC unless they added the Assistant Head Coach title in addition to his coordinator duties. Now if either of these two have their contracts expire after the 2009 season they'd essentially be free to sign with any team for any position.
* Lateral moves are only permitted if both teams agree.
If the Bears really wanted to hire away an offensive coordinator currently under contract they could always work out compensation with that team. Either with some draft picks or some money changing hands. But with the limited supply of draft picks the Bears have next year and with everyone knowing how cheap they are, this isn't really an option.
* Hiring away a coach under contract to a college is permitted.
On the NFL end there is no rule disallowing this, however if a contracted college coach chooses to interview with an NFL team it could very well piss off the school. Former Boston College head coach Jeff Jagodzinski interviewed with the N.Y. Jets last year and was subsequently fired by B.C. athletic director Gene DeFillippo. Hiring away a college coach that is a position coach or a coordinator usually comes with less drama, but you never know.
For example; If the Bears looked to a successful college program, like USC, and wanted to interview someone on their staff, like Jeremy Bates the Assistant Head Coach of the Offense/Quarterbacks Coach and former QB Coach of the Denver Broncos, they should probably inform the school of their intentions (to avoid drama), however there would be nothing that would stop them from making such a hire.
It's looking like a sure thing that at least one coach (possibly more) currently employed by the Bears will be out of a job. Who that is exactly... we'll have to wait and see. But one thing is for certain, the next guy better be able to get the most of of the franchise QB, otherwise this team could be set back another 5 years.
0 recs |
26 comments
|
Comments
Informative there wilt
good post.
Soooo you are basically telling us to make Kyle Shanahan the Assistant Head coach/Offensive Coordinator?
I think...
the Texans would just give him the same title to keep it a lateral move, but I’m not sure
by Lester A. Wiltfong Jr. on Nov 25, 2009 2:11 PM CST up reply actions
Titles away me boys
I don’t care if they call they the OC, assistant, assistant-to-the-assistant or football czar get it done.
Good info though, thanks
I choose death.
''My favorite player growing up was Kevin Garnett and he's now my least favorite player. ''-Joakim Noah
Death by incompetence
if that’s possible, the Bears will find a way…
Coaches who can outline plays on a black board are a dime a dozen. The ones who win get inside their player and motivate.
Vince Lombardi
by Fire Ron Turner on Nov 25, 2009 3:29 PM CST up reply actions
interesting
The only reason I could see K Shanahan stepping as Asst HC/OC, is to position himself for a head coaching job – since it would be a lateral move in spirit if not in name. This is with the understanding that Snuffy Smith is on thin ice as HC (which he is). Martz is a different story, since he is unemployed, but even his motive would be to move into HC if the opportunity presented itself and Lovie was shown the door.
Great post wilt.
"Chance favors the prepared mind." - Pasteur
all the stuff I read about Kyle is he wants to work with his dad
so I don’t see the Bears hiring him…
But, next week I’ll speculate on another possible offensive coordinator with Bronco ties, and not the guy I mention above, I’ll touch on Bates later
by Lester A. Wiltfong Jr. on Nov 25, 2009 2:26 PM CST up reply actions
Hey I'm fine with Kyle and Dad
Like I said before, Kyle is OC/AC and Dad is HC, or Kyle is HC and Dad is “special consultant” ala Parcels and Belichek, albeit with less intrusion.
yeah...
but we all know Lovie ain’t going no where
by Lester A. Wiltfong Jr. on Nov 25, 2009 5:46 PM CST up reply actions
All the more reason..
To bring in Shanahan, promote Marinelli to DC, and Weis or someone else not named Turner at oc
To add to your comment...
I agree and wanted to add your statement to wilt’s + if Kyle wants to work with his father, make him OC/assistant HC.
Good post.
by CharlotteBear on Nov 25, 2009 3:39 PM CST up reply actions
Weis......?!
Do we all remember how Turner came to be in Chicago? He was a failed head coach at a school with high expectations. I realize that Weis has had a fair share of success in the NFL, but I would honestly be sick if they bring in another OC from his awful college gig.
Martz sounds good to me, bring in Leslie Frazier as DC/Assistant Head Coach. He’s got the ’85 pedigree.
Rumor has it Alex Brown keeps Chris Simms' right index finger in his back pocket for good luck.
Bring on Charlie...
http://msn.foxsports.com/cfb/story/10386180/Irish-AD-Swarbrick-nixes-Weis%27-recruiting-trip
This can be interpreted many ways, one of which is Charlie shouldn’t recruit for a school he isn’t employed at.
As an Irish fan, I am on the fence if ND should fire him – I want to see what happens at Stanford. He certainly has under-performed this year (and the previous two), but his defense and turnovers are major factors. The defense received an “upgrade” at coaching last off-season, that thus far hasn’t helped on the field.
IF Charlie is fired, I think he would be a MUCH BETTER option than Mad Mike. Honestly, I don’t think the Bears current roster will suit either guy’s offensive system, but the Bears need to build around Cutler, and I believe Charlie can do a better job of that…
"Coaches who can outline plays on a black board are a dime a dozen. The ones who win get inside their player and motivate." ~Vince Lombardi
by Fire Ron Turner on Nov 25, 2009 3:42 PM CST up reply actions
How about McGuiness in 1999
what rule applies to McCaskeys McGuiness sp? in 1999, who cares, the Bears will screw up no matter what the rules are
Charlie Weis? You rally want Charlie Weis?
That is one guy I DON’T want. All the recruits in the world, 100mil, and he still can’t put together a decent season at ND. Doesn’t feel right.
Who rally wants Charlie Weis? ;)
I’m just throwing possible candidates out there.
And Notre Dame will never be “That” program again, regardless of who their coach is.
by Lester A. Wiltfong Jr. on Nov 25, 2009 9:58 PM CST up reply actions
Bottom line me pal......
Are we F’d for a long time or a short time????
"All they do is mock me, just like they did the fat fellow. All the time mocking, mocking, mocking, mocking all the time! Now, it is Babu's turn to mock "---Babu Bhatt in the Seinfeld Finale Part 2
P.S.
"The fact of the matter is the chicago bulls have never been a contender since I left..."----Johnny Kilroy
by chi_till_eye_die on Nov 25, 2009 11:16 PM CST reply actions
Help! Help! Help!
I keep seeing all of these posts for a new OC. I contend that it doesn’t really make sense to obtain a new OC without a change in the HC. Said differently, who in their right mind would want to be the new OC with Lovie’s contract ending a year later? If a new HC is named, that person will want to bring in his own coaches and name his own OC. Also, why would the Bears organization even want to chance subjecting Cutler to two OC’s in two years? Can you imagine how much that would really screw him up? I realize the word is that the Bears owe Lovie $10-$11 million in the last year of his contract but how is that being paid out? I doubt if all of the $ is being paid out in one year-the taxes would eat it alive. I suspect the $ for this last year of services is being paid out over a number of future years so the actual cash flow hit may not be so bad. If you believe that the rest of the league has caught up with the Tampa cover-2 and what Lovie has to offer, release him now (or at the end of this season), get a better HC who can hire his own and undoubtedly better OC & give Cutler the coaching & guidance he needs.
same post...
2 threads… lol
GO BEARS!!!!
by ChiTownSounds on Nov 26, 2009 11:55 AM CST up reply actions
When it comes to the Bears the only "sense" that matters is dollars and "cents"
Unless the Bears totally implode and blow the rest of the year Lovie Smith will be back as head coach
by Lester A. Wiltfong Jr. on Nov 26, 2009 11:05 PM CST up reply actions

by 

























