Weekly Musings from a Sad Blogger (4/27)

Why am I sad? Well, the draft is over. This is the last major event before training camp starts.
Anyways, I'm going to bring some sympathetic cynical thoughts on our draft picks. What I will do is run through our draft picks and hopefully offer some perspective that is mostly free of Bears Kool-Aid. Follow me inside.
Jarron Gilbert: Two things really strike me about Gilbert: intelligence and the boom-or-bust potential he has.
Yesterday, I watched this video of Gilbert (and no, it's not the pool jumping one). All of his answers were very short to the point of awkwardness. I was unimpressed, and I really hope that his athleticism makes up for it.
Second, he played at San Jose State. I know that a lot of you will point to the laundry list of players from small schools who played against sub-par competition and succeeded in the NFL. Why is this a worry for me? Well, he really made a big leap (pun intended) his senior year. He really didn't dominate until then. I'm really hoping that he's not a one-year wonder.
The positives of this pick are obvious: he is a physical specimen with great athleticism.
Juaquin Iglesias: I LOVE the value we got from this pick. He's a polished route runner with great hands who can contribute immediately, which is great for Sir Jay. What's not to like?
Well, think about when he was drafted. Iglesias was projected to not make it to #49, but he did and Jerry traded down. To me, that's an indictment of Jerry not being too impressed with Iglesias to warrant a #49 selection. Now, if Jerry really wanted Iglesias or was worried about not getting him, he could have taken him at Gilbert's spot. By all accounts, Iglesias slipped down draft boards for reasons unknown at this point. When we picked at the end of the third, it was a no-brainer pick. However, it really makes you wonder if Jerry was truly enamored with Iglesias.
Henry Melton: Can I really speak ill of a Longhorn? Why yes, yes I can.
What worries me about Melton is Danieal Manning syndrome. DMS is a dangerous disease that involves meddling coaches and their lack of foresight. Like one blogger said today, we could move Melton to the Sam. Melton has the athleticism to do so, there's no doubt about it. However, two things pop into my head: if our coaching staff meddles with him too much, DMS could set it and make this a wasted pick and we drafted Marcus Freeman, who projects to the Sam. Here's hoping Melton works out.
D.J. Moore: I've gotten more and more worried about this pick. I was elated when we got him, but my enthusiasm has been tempered since.
Moore had a terrible combine, and when I say terrible, I mean terrible. Horrendous. Pick your favorite negative connotation and stick it in there.
Yes, he was originally a 1st or 2nd round choice, but he presented himself at the combine with some negatives. His hips weren't as fluid as once thought. He's a little short. Open-field tackling is a question mark. Again, I think this was a value pick; someone who fell into our lap and Jerry got too excited from name recognition.
Johnny Knox: This one is tough to project. The positives: He's quick as hell, which will allow him to (hopefully) be a slot guy, and he has value as a returner. The negatives: He's small and played against sub-par competition.
I still don't know what to make of this. Jerry put on his small-school pirate hat on and raided Abilene Christian yet again. I hope he can be a good ST player and hopefully become a WR. At the moment, I see him as a career ST guy.
Marcus Freeman: Actually, I like this pick at the spot we got him. Move along.
Al Afalava: Oh God. That was my first reaction when I saw we picked him.
Why? Let me count the ways I hate thee:
1) He lacks NFL speed.
2) He is a Mike Brown prototype. Great against the run, bad against the pass.
3) He drunk drove, crashed into a bus shelter, and then ran. I know Melton was arrested for DUI, but that was a while ago and has been clean since. Afalava did this in February, and ever since the Nick Adenhart tragedy, I've taken a keen disliking to those idiots who drive drunk, hit something or someone, and then run.
4) His name offers two problems: First, WCG will continuously botch the spelling and it's way too close to Alfalfa.
Lance Louis: What? Seriously? I will stop here because I could write a dissertation on why this pick was awful.
Derek Kinder: I like this pick too. If he blossoms back to what he once was, we win. If he doesn't pan out, we lost out on a measly 7th round pick. Either way, we win.
Ladies and gents, no matter what we think of the Bears draft, it's 10:41 AM CDT and the Vikings still suck.
57 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
thoughts on the undrafted additions??
I kinda like the Kansas linebacker. Seems to have some potential and a chance to fight for Hillenmeyer’s spot.
I would like to see
Taufoou as the lead blocker for Forte. He would also look good on short yardage running behind our new TE Louis.
ChiFan13 give me your dissertation...
on Louis. I don’t know anything about the guy other than his impressive size with speed. I like JA going talent and project LATE in the draft.
Here's the abstract of my dissertation
If Jerry wanted a TE, he should have grabbed one of the TE’s in the draft. If he wanted OG, he should have picked a OG. If he wanted a FB, he should have picked a FB. Picking based on a sexy intangible of versatility is sometimes not the best course of action, especially with our coaching staff. I guarantee DMS sets in and he’ll be off the roster sooner rather than later.
I'M A MAN! I'M 22!
I agree...
The only good that could come from this guy is if he was good blocking FB/TE combo, and we traded Clark for someone we needed, since we’d then have two receiving TE, and no blocker.
by Jacob Hayes on Apr 27, 2009 11:57 AM CDT up reply actions
please stop
dez clark has no trade value.
if i see his name in a trade i am going to ruin this house with my anger.
You're crazy if you think a dependable receiver/blocking TE has no trade value...
It may not be huge trade value, however a backup FS or a mid round pick next year is not zero trade value.
Hint: A backup FS is better than the two FS we currently have on the roster.
dude. no trade value
maybe a 5th or 6th round pick at best.
he’s old and was a castoff from Denver. Guys like him are a dime a dozen. He’s a mediocre tight end.
LOL!!!!11ELEVEN!!!
no, you don’t get a 4th round pick for him and it’s value.
i said 5 or 6th round at best. i doubt you could get that. I don’t think you could get a 7th rounder.
nobody wants dez clark that bad. if he were cut, would somebody pick him up? perhaps but no one is giving up anything for an old TE who isn’t very good at anything.
So, I think his value is a 4th or 5th round pick.
And you literally said about two posts ago that we could get a 5th or 6th round pick.
You’re completely contridicting yourself, either he has zero worth or he is worth something.
Once again, I repeat. He has value if we can get ANYTHING for him, which you’ve already said we could. So you’re wrong. He does have value.
excuse the hyberbole but like i said, i'm not sure we could trade him
for any pick. 5th or 6th is the tops.
but if you call that value then fine. he has some value. i just dont’ find a 7th round pick to be very valuable. so to get something for him doesn’t mean much.
Once again, my point stands...
A 7th round FS is better than at least one if not all the FS on our team currently.
We currently employ the worst FS in the league.
Amen
Both Sean Smith and Johnson were available well after Chicago’s 2nd round pick. For JA not to have traded back up into the late 2nd round to address FS was a travesty. Yes, Gilbert could help the D-line, but ignoring FS to draft there is a bit like buying new rain gutters first before you patch the hole in the roof.
by slcadman2001 on Apr 27, 2009 1:56 PM CDT up reply actions
You 're probably correct.
but I think the chances of an OG or TE picked in that round are just as likely to miss the roster. If Louis was a guy that was immune to DMS, you could (at best) reach full potential in all of the measurables he has. (at worst) Have a 7th rounder not make the team.
Absolutely
You hit it right on the head. Hopefully the coaches use him wisely and we see good returns from him.
I mostly posted all of this just to stir the pot a little bit :)
I'M A MAN! I'M 22!
The Viking do indeed still suck...
Almost as much as the Packers!
The Lions… now we gotta spread a little love for the Lions, since their new logo looks SO much more fierce than their old one… we all know how important having a scary looking logo is!
Good Breakdown
Nothing overly excited me but looking back nothing really was too disappointing. A couple interesting UDFA signings in the NFC North: Tyrell Sutton to Packers and Ian Johnson to the Vikes.
by Sam Householder on Apr 27, 2009 12:17 PM CDT reply actions
most college athletes are bad behind the mic, I’m not worried about this
by Lester A. Wiltfong Jr. on Apr 27, 2009 12:31 PM CDT reply actions
Is it really surprising...
That a high first round quarterback from one of the top big time schools (which happens to be in the second biggest media market in America) gives better press interviews than a third round defensive lineman from a small school?
I am just spitballing here, but I think it is pretty likely that Sanchez has spent just a WEE bit more time getting comfortable in front of the cameras than our third rounder.
haha, good to see I wasn't the only one whom thought his name was Alfalfa
he prolly won’t make the team though
Movement to make Jeff Samardzija our closer!
Although...
I did hear that Afalava ran a 4.41 back to his house after crashing into the bus shelter…
by tfrabotta on Apr 27, 2009 1:15 PM CDT reply actions 6 recs
I like the Kinder pick. If he's healthy
He was a finalist for the Blientikof award before he got hurt.
Can’t wait til training camp to see how these guys actually look.
Formerly HBCG
Wasn't Bradley injured in college as well?
Perhaps I’m confusing his many injuries during his time here.
“the positives of this pick are obvious: he is a physical specimen with great athleticism.”
Hope to God he doesn’t turn out like Alonzo Spellman did – similar physical attributes, as well as huge potential.
Spellman was off his rocker...
"You win because of the quarterback. We have to get that position stabilized. We're fixated on that." -- Jerry Angelo (12.30.2008)
Jerry Angelo trades for Jay Cutler! (4.2.2009)
.
Talk about splitting hairs
Look, come on. Truth be told, there really aren’t any bad picks from the 4th round on. If you get starters out of those rounds, it means either A.) You got lucky, B.) Your coaching staff is great at developing prospects, or C.) All of your current starters suck.
I’m not saying these picks are worthless—far from it. They give you chances to take long shots. But that’s what they are. ALWAYS. They’re always long shots at that level. Going berserk because OMG this prospect has this problem is stupid. All of them have problems at that point in the draft (heck, most of the prospects in 1-3 have problems, too). Get over it.
FWIW, I really don’t have any problems with the picks. They all seem like developmental guys who could turn out to be really good, which is a good fit for a veteran team like the Bears.
Melton looks like the biggest reach
to me in the fourth round. I really was hoping they’d take a much-needed safety there, but maybe that’s just me. Word on NFL Network during the draft was that the Bears wanted Mike Mitchell out of Ohio and when he was scooped up by the Raiders in the second round it prompted JA to dump our pick that round. If Mitchell was the highest rated safety on JA’s board that’s fine – but to have no one except Al FavaBean next in line almost looks like he abandoned the idea of getting a safety until next year.
To me, Melton just looks like a hell of an athlete with no real position to play other than to cover kicks and punts … which is fine by me, but not good use of a fourth round pick.
Angelo said Melton had been invited for private workouts by 12 other teams
And they felt he would be gone if they hadn’t selected them with that pick.
"You win because of the quarterback. We have to get that position stabilized. We're fixated on that." -- Jerry Angelo (12.30.2008)
Jerry Angelo trades for Jay Cutler! (4.2.2009)
.
If that's what prompted JA to dump our 2nd round pick
Doesn’t that mean JA had every intention of taking that player in the 2nd. By all reports most scouts had Mitchell as no better than a 5th to 6th rounder. Why does Angelo always take one of the cute picks that no other GM (other than Al freakin’ Davis) wants or rates that highly?? I said it before and I’ll say it again. JA seems arrogant and acts like he knows something no one else does and it bites him on his ass. Totally reminds me of the Bazuin pick or even Daniel Manning. We take a guy a round or 2 before anyone else would like we can afford to waste the pick.
You have to play this game like somebody just hit your mother with a two-by-four.
YEAH!
oh wait he took devin hester in the 2nd when everyone else had him as a 5th or 6th rounder too. Look how that worked out.
If you want to crown em...
by JohnnyTruant on Apr 27, 2009 9:13 PM CDT up reply actions
Even a broken clock is right twice a day.
And being critical of a GM or draft doesn’t make you a bad fan, it makes you a true fan who wants what you feel is best for your team. My opinion may prove to be wrong but its still my opinion and I can cite several examples of JA reaches that didn’t work out. Okwo, Ariese Curry, Leon Joe, Ian Scott, Michael Haynes……
You have to play this game like somebody just hit your mother with a two-by-four.
WTF...
I know you said you were going to be pessimistic, but don’t flat out lie.
You called Johnny Knox small, he is 6-0 185 pounds. While that is not big by any means for a WR, he’s taller than Welker, Royal, and Jackson, Holt.
I can't wait to hold WCG
accountable when some of these picks turn out to be great
If you want to crown em...
by JohnnyTruant on Apr 27, 2009 9:14 PM CDT up reply actions
bc WCG and ChiFan are the same person
you heard it here first people
If you want to crown em...
by JohnnyTruant on Apr 27, 2009 9:16 PM CDT up reply actions
LOL!
While there are definitely some alter-egos on this website, I can assure you they are completely different people. You’re likely to get a beatdown for that one. :)
Be nice. Flag comments that you think are offensive. Use the "reply" button. Drink plenty of water. Compliment others. Rec comments and posts you like. Don't call people names. If you don't like someone's comment, attack the comment and not the commentor. Learn the difference in your/you're, then/than, to/too. Exercise. Relax. Stretch often. Find good in the world.
lmao
1) Duh on your part.
2) I told you I was giving it to you minus the Bears Kool-Aid. If you look up in the post, I said this:
I mostly posted all of this just to stir the pot a little bit :)
And I gave you my take in yesterday’s thread. Anything else?
I'M A MAN! I'M 22!
Will you hold yourself accountable when some of them prove to be reaches and busts?
I think we get at least 2 starters from this group and we may have quality depth from 3 or 4 more and if that’s the case this was a good to great draft when you factor in Cutler. That said, we reached for a couple of picks and Angelo has a tendency to take risks that more often than not disappoint. I hope I’m wrong. I really do.
You have to play this game like somebody just hit your mother with a two-by-four.
Umm
While that is not big by any means for a WR, he’s taller than Welker, Royal, and Jackson, Holt.
Thanks for proving my point. Never said he was a midget, but 6’0 ain’t tall.
I'M A MAN! I'M 22!
You referred to him as small, when he is definitly average height...
I love your method of refuting other people’s arguments, backtracking on what you say, calling someone small is calling him a midget (but nice job using that word to take it to the extreme) by the way, and always saying “Thanks for proving my point” as opposed to actually adding something to the conversation. You’d probably make a good politician. That was sarcasm if you didn’t catch it. I can anticipate it now.
ChiFan13’s response:
“Insert Quote here”
Thanks for proving my point.
Here we go
How did I backtrack? There’s nothing else for me to say. You got all pissy, said he wasn’t small, then said he wasn’t big but was taller than X receiver.
You contradicted yourself. So figure out what you want to say and try again.
I'M A MAN! I'M 22!
Why is it
That almost every WR we have projects ideally as a slot guy? Except for Davis, who projects ideally as a janitor? At some point, don’t we need someone who’s fast and polished enough to line up at flanker?
"Well, we didn't block real good but we made up for it by not tackling."
- John McKay

by 





















