Weekly Musings from a Happy Blogger (7/13)
We've discussed everything we can about the Chicago Bears. In order to not beat any more horses, I'll be detailing everything you need to know about the upcoming college football season before training camp starts.
Mark Schlabach published his Top 25 in May; for this week's column, I'll be detailing my Top 20 college football teams for 2009 (only 20 for the sake of time). Hopefully, this will be something new for y'all to argue and complain about.
Let's get it started.
|
Preseason Rankings |
||
|
ChiFan13 |
Mark Schlabach |
|
| 1. | Florida | Florida |
| 2. | Texas | Texas |
| 3. | Oklahoma | Oklahoma |
| 4. | USC | USC |
| 5. |
Ole Miss |
Virginia Tech |
| 6. | Virginia Tech | Ohio State |
| 7. | Oklahoma State | Ole Miss |
| 8. | Alabama | Alabama |
| 9. | Ohio State | Penn State |
| 10. | Penn State | Oklahoma State |
| 11. | LSU | Oregon |
| 12. | Oregon | LSU |
| 13. | Boise State | Cal |
| 14. | Cal | Boise State |
| 15. | Georgia Tech | Georgia Tech |
| 16. | TCU | Georgia |
| 17. | Notre Dame | Notre Dame |
| 18. | Georgia | TCU |
| 19. | Nebraska | Iowa |
| 20. | Iowa | Nebraska |
1.
Florida Gators
The defending national champions return all eleven starters on defense, media darling Tim Tebow, and enough offensive weapons to make them the most dangerous team in the country. They play seven games at home (eight if you count the neutral-site contest against Georgia). Bottom line? Their ridiculous secondary combined with Tebow could equal another national championship for the Gators.
Schlabach's #1: Florida Gators
Key losses: WR Percy Harvin, WR Louis Murphy, TE Cornelius Ingram
Key games: @ LSU (October 10); vs. Georgia (October 31); @ South Carolina (November 14)
2.
Texas Longhorns
Some of you who have been around for a while will call me a homer for making Texas #2. Go for it. It's tough to knock the Longhorn offense, with Heisman hopeful Colt McCoy, Jordan Shipley, TE Blaine Irby (lost for most of 2008 due to injury) and a more experienced offensive line. Defensively, the Longhorns lost DL starters Brian Orakpo and Henry Melton, but return one of the top LB's in the country, Sergio Kindle. Their secondary was very green last year, but that group will play much better and not make the freshmen mistakes of 2008. If they can get past Oklahoma and Oklahoma State, expect to see a Gators - Longhorns national championship.
Schlabach's #2: Texas Longhorns
Key losses: DE Brian Orakpo, DT Roy Miller, DE Henry Melton, RB Chris Ogbonnaya
Key games: vs. Oklahoma (October 17); @ Oklahoma State (October 31); @ Baylor (November 14)
The good news for the Sooner faithful? They return many key pieces from their 2008 NC game run, including QB Sam Bradford (defending Heisman winner), RB Demarco Murray, TE Jermaine Gresham, and DT Gerald McCoy. However, the Sooners have to replace four starters on the offensive line and two starters at both safety positions. Regardless, the Sooners will be one of the top teams this year. Whoever can survive the annual Big XII South gauntlet will most likely face the Gators in the national championship game.
Schlabach's #3: Oklahoma Sooners
Key losses: OT Phil Loadholt, WR Juaquin Iglesias, S Nic Harris, OG Duke Robinson, WR Manuel Johnson
Key games: vs. Texas (October 17); @ Nebraska (November 7); Oklahoma State (November 28)
4.
USC Trojans
If this was any other team, USC would have a tough time regrouping after losing so many quality players to the NFL draft. However, this is USC; like the other top teams on this list, they don't rebuild - they reload. I have them at an early #4 because of the talent that is returning, as well as some fresh faces from their recruiting class. However, they have a tough slate of games in the month of October. I don't see them having an undefeated season this year.
Schlabach's #4: USC Trojans
Key losses: QB Mark Sanchez, LB Brian Cushing, LB Clay Matthews, LB Rey Maualuga, DT Fili Moala, WR Patrick Turner, LB Kaluka Maiava, DE Kyle Moore
Key games: @ Ohio State (September 12); @ Cal (October 3); @ Notre Dame (October 17); @ Oregon (October 31)
5.
Mississippi Rebels
Everyone's been giddy at the 2009 prospects of Ole Miss after their win over Texas Tech in the Cotton Bowl. However, they're not overrated. Ole Miss returns a number of offensive weapons (most notably QB Jevan Snead) and reloads on defense. The Rebels lost two excellent players in OT Michael Oher and DT Peria Jerry; Jerry's shoes will be filled by veteran players. The big question mark for the Rebs is at the LT position. They have a favorable schedule, playing both Alabama and LSU at home. Do I think that the Rebels are this good? Not particularly; they have good players at key positions and have the easiest path to become SEC West champions, thus their #5 ranking.
Schlabach's #5: Virginia Tech Hokies
Key losses: OT Michael Oher, DT Peria Jerry, WR Mike Wallace, S Jamarca Sanford
Key games: vs. Alabama (October 10); vs. LSU (November 21)
6.
Virginia Tech Hokies
Virginia Tech is loaded offensively, sporting QB Tyrod Taylor and RB Darren Evans along with a retooled offensive line. However, Virginia Tech has some problems. Their WR's severely underperformed last season and their defense is a little shaky. Normally, this would be a quick toss out of the top 10 from me. Their saving grace is their schedule; minus the Georgia Tech contest and the neutral-field Alabama game, their toughest games are at home.
Schlabach's #6: Ohio State Buckeyes
Key losses: S Victor Harris
Key games: vs. Alabama (September 5); vs. Nebraska (September 19); @ Georgia Tech (October 17); vs. North Carolina (October 29)
7.
Oklahoma State Cowboys
Offensively, the Cowboys are stacked. They return QB Zac Robinson, RB Kendall Hunter, and WR Dez Bryant. In the defensively-iffy Big XII South, the Cowboys should contend to be the Big XII South champions. However, their defense isn't as strong as Texas or Oklahoma and also lost two starters on the offensive line. Knowing all of that, the reason they're #7 to me is because of two main factors: 1) They play two of their three key games at home and 2) their offense is so explosive that their defense might not matter.
Schlabach's #7: Mississippi Rebels
Key losses: TE Brandon Pettigrew
Key games: vs. Georgia (September 5); vs. Texas (October 31); @ Oklahoma (November 28)
8.
Alabama Crimson Tide
Why is Alabama ranked so high? They're returning nine starters on defense along with dangerous WR Julio Jones and play two key games at home. Why should Alabama be ranked lower? They lost three starters on the offensive line along with their starting RB and QB. Honestly, this is a difficult team to predict. In the defensively-heavy SEC, they'll be tough enough to hold down opposing teams and let the offense sputter along (sound familiar?). The October 10 date at Mississippi will help clear up who the SEC West champions will be.
Schlabach's #8: Alabama
Key losses: OT Andre Smith, RB Glen Coffee, C Antoine Caldwell, S Rashad Johnson, QB John Parker Wilson
Key games: vs. Virginia Tech (September 5); @ Mississippi (October 10); vs. LSU (November 7)
9.
Ohio State Buckeyes
This is where the USC theory comes into play. Ohio State has been a perennial powerhouse for the past few years, yet they lost an enormous amount of talent to the NFL draft. They should be able to reload, right? Well, sort of. QB Terrelle Pryor returns, as well as their offensive and defensive lines. Ohio State lost two starting linebackers and two corners as well as Chris "Beanie" Wells and two of their WR's. They have talent coming into those trouble areas, but will it be enough? Ohio State warrants this ranking from me due to Pryor's return, as well as hosting two of the three key games this season.
Schlabach's #9: Penn State Nittany Lions
Key losses: CB Malcolm Jenkins, RB Chris Wells, LB James Laurinaitis, WR Brian Robiskie, CB Donald Washington, WR Brian Hartline, LB Marcus Freeman, QB Todd Boeckman
Key games: vs. USC (September 12); @ Penn State (November 7); vs. Iowa (November 14)
10.
Penn State Nittany Lions
On paper, Penn State shouldn't be on this list. They lost both starting WR's along with having to rebuild both their offensive and defensive lines. So why are they here? They play in the snoozing Big 10 (meaning that even with this team, they'll challenge for the conference crown) and they have a friendly schedule, playing both Iowa and Ohio State at home.
Schlabach's #10: Oklahoma State Cowboys
Key losses: DE Aaron Maybin, WR Derrick Williams, WR Deon Butler, OG Rick Ohrnberger, C A.Q. Shipley
Key games: vs. Iowa (September 26); vs. Ohio State (November 7)
11.
LSU Tigers
Similar to Oklahoma State, LSU has more promise on offense than defense in 2009. They return QB Jordan Jefferson, RB Charles Scott, and WR Brandon LaFell, along with a solid offensive line. LSU must rebuild their defensive line to be in contention for the SEC West. Compounding that problem, they play three of their toughest games on the road, including two that will help decide the SEC West champions. Regardless, LSU is good enough to garner the #11 ranking.
Schlabach's #11: Oregon
Key losses: DE Tyson Jackson, FB Quinn Johnson, OG Herman Johnson, S Curtis Taylor, WR Demetrius Byrd, DT Ricky Jean-Francois
Key games: @ Georgia (October 3); vs. Florida (October 10); @ Alabama (November 7); @ Mississippi (November 21)
12.
Oregon Ducks
Oregon has a dual-threat QB in Jeremiah Masoli and a stellar RB in LeGarrette Blount. That's about all they have after the NFL and graduation took three starters on the OL, DL, and secondary. However, they were blessed with a mostly-friendly schedule, with three of their top Pac-10 games hosted at home. The September 3rd game against Boise State game is an early test for both teams.
Schlabach's #12: LSU
Key losses: S Patrick Chung, CB Jarius Byrd, C Max Unger, OT Fenuki Tupou, DT Ra'Shon Harris, DE Nick Reed
Key games: @ Boise State (September 3); vs. Utah (September 19); vs. Cal (September 26); vs. USC (October 31)
13.
Boise State Broncos
Boise State looks to have a solid team and an easy schedule. They return their starting QB, two of their WR's, three other starters in the offense, four starters in the secondary, and two other starters on the defense. Their offensive line needs to play more consistent than last year, but they're stacked otherwise. The first game of the season versus Oregon will prove whether the Broncos are a BCS-worthy team.
Schlabach's #13: California Golden Bears
Key losses: RB Ian Johnson, WR Jeremy Childs
Key games: vs. Oregon (September 3)
14.
California Golden Bears
Cal should be able to truly compete in the Pac-10 this year. Their savior is Heisman hopeful RB Jahvid Best. Their problems include their linebacking corps and WR's. If Jeff Tedford is able to fill the holes at linebacker, the Golden Bears will challenge USC and Oregon for the Pac-10 title.
Schlabach's #14: Boise State Broncos
Key losses: C Alex Mack, LB Zack Follett, TE Cameron Morrah
Key games: @ Oregon (September 26); vs. USC (October 3)
15.
Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets
Former Navy coach Paul Johnson has successfully implemented his triple option-spread offense at Georgia Tech. Will this be the year he moves his team in for a BCS berth? Well, maybe. Nine starters return on offense, as well as a majority of their defense. However, they lost three defensive linemen, which could be a huge loss. Their hardest games in the ACC are played at home as well as their contest versus in-state rival Georgia.
Schlabach's #15: Georgia Tech
Key losses: DE Michael Johnson, OT Andrew Gardner, DT Vance Walker, DT Darryl Richard
Key games: vs. North Carolina (September 26); vs. Virginia Tech (October 17); vs. Georgia (November 28)
16.
TCU Horned Frogs
Like the Bears, TCU has been known as a defensively strong team. However, both the Bears and the Horned Frogs will most likely be known for their offensive prowess this year. The Horned Frogs return their QB, top WR, and two of their RB's. On defense, they must replace seven of their starters, but the #1 sack producer last year, DE Jerry Hughes, is back. The Utah game in 2008 was spectacular, and this game should be no different.
Schlabach's #16: Georgia Bulldogs
Key losses: LB Jason Phillips, LB Robert Henson, RB Aaron Brown, LB Stephen Hodge, C Blake Schlueter
Key games: @ BYU (October 24); vs. Utah (November 14)
17.
Notre Dame Fighting Irish
If Charlie Weis can't get it done this year, he deserves to be fired. He's returning ten starters on offense and a lot of experience all over his team. The only area of major concern is at RB, which has to improve from last year's horrendous performance. Even their schedule is set up for them to win, with the home game against USC the only difficult game on the schedule. However, I'm still leery of this team. Call it a gut instinct or whatever you want, but I'm not as sold as some are on this team.
Schlabach's #17: Notre Dame
Key losses: S David Bruton
Key games: vs. USC (October 17); vs. Navy (November 7)
18.
Georgia Bulldogs
Mark Schlabach has Georgia ranked at #16; I don't see where he gets that ranking. Georgia has to replace their starting QB and RB, along with three key defensive starters. In other words, don't expect their offense to be as explosive as it was in 2008. Defensively, the Bulldogs aren't losing as much and should be able to ably compete in the SEC.
Schlabach's #18: TCU Horned Frogs
Key losses: QB Matthew Stafford, RB Knowshon Moreno, WR Mohamed Massaquoi, CB Asher Allen, DT Corey Irvin, DE Jarius Wynn
Key games: @ Oklahoma State (September 5); vs. LSU (October 3); vs. Florida (October 31); @ Georgia Tech (November 28)
19.
Nebraska Cornhuskers
Nebraska is a tough team to read. Their defense is anchored by Ndamukong Suh, my #1 DT prospect at the moment. Unfortunately for the Husker faithful, they lost QB Joe Ganz along with two of their starting WR's. But, they do have two good running backs, along with dual-threat QB Zac Lee. Their schedule isn't as favorable as some, playing Virginia Tech and potential Big XII champion Kansas on the road. This may not be the year for Nebraska, but expect them to challenge for the Big XII championship in the near future.
Schlabach's #19: Iowa Hawkeyes
Key losses: LB Cody Glenn, OG Matt Slauson, OT Lydon Murtha, QB Joe Ganz
Key games: @ Virginia Tech (September 19); vs. Oklahoma (November 7); @ Kansas (November 14)
20. 
Iowa returns QB Ricky Stanzi and arguably the best offensive line in the country. However, they also have to replace the losses of RB Shonn Greene and defensive line mainstays Mitch King and Matt Kroul. The other problem the Hawkeyes may run into are the seemingly constant arrests of their players. Their schedule is not friendly, either; they'll play at Penn State, Wisconsin, and Ohio State. Even their first game against Northern Iowa isn't a lock.
Schlabach's #20: Nebraska Cornhuskers
Key losses: RB Shonn Greene, CB Brian Fletcher, OT Seth Olsen, TE Brandon Myers, DE Mitch King, DT Matt Kroul
Key games: vs. Northern Iowa (September 5); @ Penn State (September 26); @ Ohio State (November 14)
-----
Last week's article: ChiFan's Top NCAA Games to See in 2009
0 recs |
19 comments
|
Comments
#17 Notre Dame
The Irish has been stinkin’ up the joint ever since Holtz left. Whenever they’ve happened to crack the top 25 in the past decade or so, It’s only because of past glory. They’re to high and mighty to recruit the kind of players it takes to compete with the real “Top” programs in the NCAA. I understand high academic standards and all but, Football is the reason Notre Dame has the tradition it does.
by Big Ike on Jul 13, 2009 1:03 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
They’re to high and mighty to recruit the kind of players it takes to compete with the real "Top" programs in the NCAA. I understand high academic standards and all
So would you rather they soil the institution as a whole and recruit someone who doesn’t meet academic standards? There’s already a blueprint for that, it’s called Florida State. How is that fair to the rest of the students who aren’t good at football?
I'm teaching fools some basic rules.- MR.T
by Ditkavsworld on Jul 13, 2009 1:33 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
Yeah, I have no problem with them keeping their standards.
I think it’s refreshing to see a school actually stick to their guns and only recruit if they meet the academic standards. And not only recruit, but actually enforce it ala Julius Jones. They sat his ass in a heartbeat when he dropped his grades, and he was by far their most productive back.
"Well, we didn't block real good but we made up for it by not tackling."
- John McKay
by JerBear50 on Jul 14, 2009 4:20 AM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
Tebow
Tebow might go down as the greatest college player to ever play football. If he can pull off another National Championship and Heisman he’ll cement his legacy.
I’m not a huge college football fan, but I’ll watch Florida this year so I can see him play.
by Lester A. Wiltfong Jr. on Jul 13, 2009 1:36 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
I hate Tebow w/ a passion
But I can agree w/ what you’re saying. I think if he wins either the Heisman or another NC he’ll go down as the best ever. He wins the Heisman, he’ll have two making him the second player ever to accomplish that feat, I believe. If he wins another National Championship, he’ll have three, which is pretty damn impressive. I think he’s gonna shut all his critics up this year that say he can’t make it in the NFL.
"The phone's for you, I think it's the Devil."
by Acreman20 on Jul 13, 2009 5:08 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
Well
Even if he wins another Heisman/NC, that has no bearing on how his NFL career will go.
I'M A MAN! I'M 23!
by ChiFan13 on Jul 13, 2009 5:18 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
I love the guy
but I have no confidence in his transition to the NFL. That’s ok though, cause we get one more year of dominance, and most importantly, embarrassing the hell out of Bowden and FSU. I can only pray that OSU and the sweater vest somehow stumble their way into the NC against them again…
"Well, we didn't block real good but we made up for it by not tackling."
- John McKay
by JerBear50 on Jul 14, 2009 4:23 AM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
I'm with ChiFan and JerBear
Tebow at this point, is not an NFL QB.
Anybody know Tebow’s 40 time?
by rdent4hof on Jul 14, 2009 8:51 AM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
I remember doing some research
on him when it looked like he might come out for the 2009 draft. Iirc, it has been reported from 4.4 – 4.6 seconds.
I don’t think Tebow is yet an NFL QB, but I also won’t discount the possibility of him developing into one either. He’s still young, and will benefit greatly from another year in college.
LSU Tigers Baseball... NCAA National Champions- 2009.
by Dane Noble on Jul 14, 2009 9:41 AM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
#21
= BALL STATE!!!
Haha, jk. But I couldn’t resist.
"A lot of fans were drawn to me because they knew that whatever the score was, I was going to run as hard as I could on every play. You don't have that now, you have guys waiting for next week or even next year." - Walter Payton
by HoneyBear on Jul 13, 2009 1:48 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
On Oklahoma...
I said this in last weeks post, but on the defensive side of the ball, the Sooners really only have to replace the starting SS. Last year Nic Harris played a lot at MLB, due to the insane amount of injuries at that position, causing the incumbent starter at FS Quinton Michael saw a lot of action. You also forgot to mention that they will be returning everyone on the 2 deep of their front 7, minus one backup, and the defense will also receive a jolt from the return of MLB Ryan Reynolds, who is every bit as good as Kindle and on the positive side doesn’t run his car into apartment buildings, and DE Austin English, who was widely considered the best speed rusher in the Big 12 two seasons ago. Possibly giving them the most talented front seven in the nation.
by chase17 on Jul 13, 2009 4:28 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
Kindle did work on that one
Regardless, the front seven will be good. However, I’m not exactly sold on the secondary yet, and you do have some pretty large holes to fill along the OL.
I'M A MAN! I'M 23!
by ChiFan13 on Jul 13, 2009 4:50 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
I am...
sold on the secondary, the reason being we some really talented CBs returning, who I believe were both all Big 12 performers last season, plus I expect OU’s pass rush to be so sick that the secondary won’t be stuck in coverage too long.
Also, I understand what you are saying about the holes on the O-Line, but everything I’ve heard about the new players is that they are much more suited for the no-huddle offense because they are all super athletic, the lack of athleticism on that O-Line last year was shown in close games last year by the O-Line wearing down in the 4th quarter, i.e. the Texas and Florida games. Plus we have Trent Williams returning, and that guy was the best player on our O-Line last season.
by chase17 on Jul 13, 2009 7:17 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
Oh and...
Al Afalava played for Oregon State not Oregon.
by chase17 on Jul 13, 2009 4:32 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
Love the love for Iowa, but I'm not sold.
I think our lines (both sides) will be above average but I question our secondary and TE’s. Running back will be just fine. Watch out for Jewel Hampton. Guy’s a stud.
If you can't laugh at yourself you must not be very funny.
by Just Dave on Jul 13, 2009 10:21 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
That was actually one of the tougher decisions for me
Originally, I had Kansas in that spot and went back and forth on that selection for a while. If there’s any team that has the opportunity to fall like a log, it’s Iowa.
Quick question for ya since you’re a Hawkeye….didn’t Hampton injure himself recently?
I'M A MAN! I'M 23!
by ChiFan13 on Jul 14, 2009 4:50 AM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
That's the rumor. Hurt his knee.
But Iowa’s keeping quiet. I’ve heard nothing official. Would definitely take them out of the top 20 without him.
If you can't laugh at yourself you must not be very funny.
by Just Dave on Jul 14, 2009 2:47 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs

by 






















