Windy City Gridiron: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Jeff Sullivan's MLB Trade Deadline Primer

Bears #1 Off Season Need Is Free Safety

Wcg_thumb_notes_medium 

OK, it's official.  The readers of Windy City Gridiron have spoken.  In an article posted Monday by Kev, he put it to a poll; What is the Chicago Bears absolute biggest need?  And with over total 900 votes cast, and with 26% of the vote, ahead of the 21% defensive end garnered, free safety comes out on top.  I can't say I'm surprised.  It's what I voted.  My thought is if you don't have one on the roster it's gotta be a pretty big need.

I've already touched on the subject a couple times, here, and here.  So after the jump I'll get into a few other options the Bears have in finding an actual free safety to roam the secondary in Lovie Smith's Tampa 2.

Star-divide

While the news that the New Orleans Saints will not slap the Franchise Tag on Darren Sharper could be considered good for Bears fans, I don't see him as someone the Bears would pursue.  They could have had him last year yet passed, and now he's a year older and...  Signing him just doesn't have a Bears feel to it.  I think he'd be a great couple year stop gap until they could find a younger and better replacement (maybe with their #1 draft pick in 2011), but I'd be real surprised if Jerry Angelo goes that route.  Honestly I'd be surprised if the Bears looked for a free safety in the free agent pool at all.  One, because there isn't much in there, and two, I think they feel that can draft a guy that could come in and start for them.  And let's not forget option three, where the arrogance of the Bears staff feels they have their FS on the roster.  Shudder...

After initially not being very high on possibly going after Ryan Clark of the Steelers, I've had a change of heart.  Basically because anyone that has played the position would be an upgrade for Chicago.  Clark played in 15 games last year picking off 3 passes and making 89 tackles.  The Steelers want him to return and he'd like to be a Steeler, but if they can't work out a deal the Bears may get a bid in.

The only other option I can see among the unrestricted free agents is Will Allen of the Buccaneers.  But I see him more like a Josh Bullocks type signing.  He's has some experience at free safety, he's just not very good.

With the CBA not resolved it really put a damper on the free agent pool.  And with the Bears not having their first or second round picks this year, it really takes them out of making a play for any of the restricted free agents.  The Bears best bet will be to find a free safety in the draft. 

After getting laughed at with their 2009 7th round selection of Al Afalava by most "experts", the Bears got the last laugh with him seeing significant playing time as a rookie.  The Bears could find their guy with a late draft pick.  It could happen...  Here are a few more prospects to keep an eye out for...

Jonathon Amaya of Nevada, who will be at the NFL Combine, is known as a speed guy.  He's run the forty in the 4.4 vicinity.  And he was voted 2nd team all WAC.  He's another guy that played in the Texas vs The Nation college all-star game.  Most draft sites have him as a 7th rounder at best, but if he tests well in Indy he could get himself noticed.

All Mountain West 1st teamer Robert Johnson from Utah is an intriguing prospect.  He ran some track in junior college, he is known for his center-fieldlike skills while playing zone coverage, but his slight frame may scare away some teams.  He is 6'2", but only 197 pounds.  We'll have to see how he tests out at his pro day (March 8). as he wasn't invited to the combine.  NFLDraftscout.com has him rated as a 5th-6th round prospect.

Nick Polk of Indiana, or DB39, as he'll be known at the combine is said to have a strong safety build (5'11" 213 and an affinity for the weight room), but with free safety speed.  As a redshirt freshman in 2006 he started 9 games at wide receiver.  Some sites have him going undrafted and others have him around the 5th-6th round.

Southern Mississippi FS Eddie Hicks has 38 consecutive starts and 13 career interceptions.  He's another rangy center-field type that could use some added bulk (6'2" 188), but claims to be able to consistently run under 4.5 for his forty.  He also didn't get the combine invite (his pro day is March 22), but he's working on his speed with 1992 Olympic sprinter Ed Lovelace.

My perfect scenario would be for the Bears to sign Sharper to a 2 year deal, and then draft a FS to groom into the roll.  But as I don't expect the Bears to drop the cash to sign a free agent, I hope they draft at least 2 legitimate free safeties.

1 recs  |  Comment 72 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Around SB Nation

Suck In the Middle

Jul 2010 from Viva El Birdos - 409 comments

The Connect: 07/29/10

Jul 2010 from The 7th Floor - 1 comment

Embattled LSU Visits Auburn

Jul 2010 from Track Em Tigers - 4 comments

Comments

Display:

Sharper is a better bet...

than drafting a FS, but I agree that the Bears do not seem likely to go after Sharper. I see either Peppers or Kampman being signed to address the DE position. Next up drafting the best FS prospect (Chancellor IMO). I think Payne and Afalava can hold down the SS spot with Bullocks on to mentor/backup the FS spot. I hope the Bears address the DT spot, but I see them banking on Gilbert and Harris.
What the Bears cannot afford to do is wait for a late round “gem” to save the FS debacle they have created. They need to go with the high talent draftee (perhaps trade up?) or the proven veteran. Anything less will provide the fans with more fodder to have Lovie and JA drawn and quartered! (or drawn and buttered if you prefer).

IT'S NOT TOO LATE TO FIRE LOVIE!

by LostInSTL on Feb 25, 2010 10:24 AM CST reply actions  

I don't want Bullocks mentoring anyone

but I wouldn’t mind him as a back up… unless a better option can be found

by Lester A. Wiltfong Jr. on Feb 25, 2010 10:38 AM CST up reply actions  

That's why I slashed it...

with backup! It’s like the old MAD magazine bit about “what they say vs. what they mean”. Lovie says X, but really he means Y.

IT'S NOT TOO LATE TO FIRE LOVIE!

by LostInSTL on Feb 25, 2010 10:42 AM CST up reply actions  

Nor will Sharper target the Bears

He hates the cover-2, and his skill set is better suited for an attacking type of secondary; one where he can roam freely and make plays. He’ll avoid Halas Hall like the black plague.

"The country is full of good coaches. What it takes to win is a bunch of interested players." -Don Coryell, ex-San Diego Chargers Coach

by propheteer on Feb 25, 2010 10:40 AM CST up reply actions  

Sharper's too old!

How many more seasons does Sharper have? I’d be much happier if the Bears went after a player who could produce for 4-5 years down the road. I’m generally opposed to signing players over 32 years old for more than one year. There are a few exceptions but I would rather see us gamble on someone who is already a Bear than someone from outside the system. Right now we have no one within the system worth a gamble so we must go outside, but I hope we go younger.

"Sometimes I wonder whether the world is being run by smart people who are putting us on or by imbeciles who really mean it." - Mark Twain

by phastphil on Feb 25, 2010 10:49 AM CST up reply actions  

Sharper's just a stop gap.

We can use him for a year and draft a stud next year, maybe keep him on to mentor the kid …

by Irish Bears Fan on Feb 26, 2010 3:31 AM CST up reply actions  

they won't go after a safety at all

Oddly enough, Lovie Smith has said in the past that he is fine with the players we have on tap for FS. Odd because he seems to think you can plug anyone in back there and have them be successful. He may be right if the D line gets consistent pressure on the QB. I don’t agree with him though. Mike Brown showed what a good safety can do to help a defense.

"I am not an animal!" - Merrick

by Maelvampyre on Feb 25, 2010 10:42 AM CST reply actions  

what a difference a year makes

It’s funny that we have a thread on this topic. I recall advocating that we bring in Sharper last offseason, and most of WCG thinking that it was terrible idea.

Another Pro Bowl and 9 more INTs later, . . .

by MakeHalasProud on Feb 25, 2010 10:43 AM CST reply actions  

Maybe we could pick up Dunta

and move Tillman. Otherwise i would like to see the bears go for Rolle(assuming he is released).

by Jhitt81 on Feb 25, 2010 11:16 AM CST reply actions  

As to DE.

I always thought Vernon Gholston would be better with his hand on the ground. He has sucked it up in NY, maybe they’re ready to let him go for cheap(like say a 3 and jamar williams).

by Jhitt81 on Feb 25, 2010 11:20 AM CST reply actions  

Good point

Probably better to wait until they cut him.

by Jhitt81 on Feb 25, 2010 1:36 PM CST up reply actions  

i agree with that if/when hes cut

hes intriguing prospect as a rusher if he can be had for cheap id be all for it

by Bear Lovin 21 on Feb 25, 2010 1:50 PM CST up reply actions  

Gholston is a great example

of a guy that had a great combine, but on film he was inconsistent. Bust.

by Lester A. Wiltfong Jr. on Feb 25, 2010 1:53 PM CST up reply actions  

Whoa. Whoa. Whoa. Get rid of Williams ?

The guy gets one start, makes 19 tackles (picking up Hillenmeyers whiffs) and we trade him ? Please – the guy is talented – I’d like to see them experiment with him at FS, he’s 6’0 230 lbs …

by Irish Bears Fan on Feb 26, 2010 3:34 AM CST up reply actions  

I’ve had enough of the experimenting from this crew.

"F*** everybody outside of Halas Hall. BEARDOWN" - WavyGravy
"if we need it, we’re not drafting it. not high anyway. look for Angelo to go after a DL/DE – because that’s just the kind of asshat he is.." - junkhorse
"44 years of football history and nothing to show for it. I wish I wasn’t banned at the Norseman.." - tfrabotta

by Spongie on Feb 26, 2010 6:00 PM CST up reply actions  

Don't need to trade for any more speedy busts

Unless you think our Defensive brain trust is better than NY’s and can fix him. If he can be picked up off the waiver wire then maybe give him a look but don’t give up anything for him.

by SaintCee on Feb 26, 2010 3:53 AM CST up reply actions  

Free Safety wasnt an issue till we let go of Mike Brown, Chris Harris, Hell Mike Green was decent

When Rolle hits free agency….we need to go ALL OUT!

Through the draft here are a few guys i like and we might be able to snag in round 3.

1. Kam Chancellor(No it Alls man crush)- Would be an imposing presence we lack.

2. Larry Asante- smaller guy but from what i hear he brings the wood

3. Major Wright- i think he fits in well with what he have

what you guys think?

by Bear Lovin 21 on Feb 25, 2010 11:52 AM CST reply actions  

Hell

Todd Johnson was an alright back fill

"Hey, the offensive linemen are the biggest guys on the field, they're bigger than everybody else, and that's what make them the biggest guys on the field." -Madden

by BearNecessities on Feb 26, 2010 3:10 AM CST up reply actions  

Man that guy had some monster hits!

He was a guy i loved watching on special teams he blew people up like there was no tomorrow.

by Bear Lovin 21 on Feb 26, 2010 9:17 AM CST up reply actions  

FS

What about Antrel Rolle who is expected to be cut from the Cardinals. He’s younger, has experience ,and would give the Bears to draft and groom an actual free safety from the draft. I don’t think that they are going to go for Sharper considering he doesn’t want to play the cover 2 and he’s old, and relying on a rookie from the later rounds making a big impact their first year is a risky proposition.

by Abear on Feb 25, 2010 11:53 AM CST reply actions  

Be an interesting idea

But that could turn into a bidding war fast, and I wouldn’t want to throw too much money at any one player this offseason, not with 3-4 clear needs to be addressed before we’re even legitimately a contender.

by JoCro on Feb 25, 2010 8:07 PM CST up reply actions  

DE is way more of a need

I realize FS is “sore” spot, but it doesn’t even come close to the abyss/black hole that is the DE position. The back of the secondary isn’t an issue if the line is doing its job. With that being said, I’d be find with drafting one in the 3rd round, or signing Rolle if he’s cut.

"The country is full of good coaches. What it takes to win is a bunch of interested players." -Don Coryell, ex-San Diego Chargers Coach

by propheteer on Feb 25, 2010 12:50 PM CST reply actions  

You guys do realize .....

….. that if the D-line gets fixed it will help the secondary out MORE than adding a new member to that secondary . With a better pass rush the guys in the secondary won’t have to cover as long and thats been our biggest issue , those guys having to cover for what seems like an eternity . Give them a pass rush and all that changes . I am all for adding more talent at FS , say Antrel Rolle or someone via the draft , but our biggest need , no way .

by MidWayMonster54 on Feb 25, 2010 12:57 PM CST reply actions  

I have been on record many times saying

Kampan and Rolle help us more than peppers.
There will be situations were the line doesnt get pressure and id feel more comftorable with Rolle back there as oppose to Bullocks

by Bear Lovin 21 on Feb 25, 2010 1:09 PM CST up reply actions  

Kampmann blew his knee out ...

We need more players with blown up kneecaps …. Peppers is healthy and looked good in the pro bowl.

by Irish Bears Fan on Feb 26, 2010 3:35 AM CST up reply actions  

Peppers only comes to play when he's motivated. The big contract is what motivated him.

If the Bears were to bring him in he’d be like all our other big contract/low performance players. He’s like Herschel Walker, one of those guys who doesn’t really love the game, just blessed with the physical talent to play. He has bust written all over him for what will be his last big contract. Having said that, I just realized the Bears will probably sign him.

by BigGeorgeTX on Feb 26, 2010 10:13 AM CST up reply actions  

Yes, Lester i know

I was one of the ones who voted guard.
I belive FS/DE are both important so why not solve both by signing kampan and rolle?

by Bear Lovin 21 on Feb 25, 2010 1:51 PM CST up reply actions  

you voted Guard!

That would have made for ian interesting post!

by Lester A. Wiltfong Jr. on Feb 25, 2010 1:55 PM CST up reply actions  

I'd put twenty bucks on...

Myron Lewis out of Vanderbilt being the FS we grab in the draft.

6ft 2in, 205lbs, played both CB and FS, projects as either a FS or Cover 2 Corner in the NFL.

Also, currently ranked as a late 4th, early 5th round pick.

As I mention in passing in my post tonight, Vandy + Need + Value = Bears FS.

Associate Writer - WindyCityGridiron.com

by Jacob Hayes on Feb 25, 2010 1:32 PM CST reply actions  

+1
As I mention in passing in my post tonight, Vandy + Need + Value = Bears FS.

And the Vandy reunion tour continues!

"The country is full of good coaches. What it takes to win is a bunch of interested players." -Don Coryell, ex-San Diego Chargers Coach

by propheteer on Feb 25, 2010 1:50 PM CST up reply actions  

Wow...

that dude has Bears written all over him.

Walter Payton lives on!!!

by monsterman34 on Feb 25, 2010 8:47 PM CST up reply actions  

I dont understand why the Bears cant/wont address both positions

via the FA. If there is a viable player for FS/DE why not try to get both? Yes I realize it comes down to the organization not wanting to spend to much $$. We dont have very many draft picks so it is imperative that we use FA. Plus I would think JA and Smith are aware that this is a win or else season so they SHOULD be more aggressive in FA. There are to many needs on defense to hope to draft a player who will be a starter.

by chigrl on Feb 25, 2010 2:48 PM CST reply actions  

I think Ginnie will come through.

She’ll have told them to get one big FA signing, it has to be Peppers. If we get Peppers then you can play FS ChiGirl !

by Irish Bears Fan on Feb 26, 2010 3:37 AM CST up reply actions  

haha very funny

and I’ll promise to do my very best.

by chigrl on Feb 28, 2010 1:35 AM CST up reply actions  

Rolle or Clark

Lets get Antrell Rolle in FA and draft Myron Rolle in the 5th round. And eventually have the Rolle brothers play alongside each other. And make a song about them to the lyrics of Tootsie Rolle!!!!!!

"How sad, another victim of the Night Nurses from Jersey."

by ANYTIME09 on Feb 25, 2010 3:25 PM CST reply actions  

We should load up on players from Vanderbilt, after all they win the SEC Championship every year.

by gbranton on Feb 25, 2010 3:31 PM CST reply actions  

I would love to see us get Sharper,

they should have picked him up last year. The Bears passed on him last year and it was a no brainer. That combined with them getting rid of Chris Harris truly makes me believe that they have no judge of talent at that position whatsoever. I have questioned their ability to judge talent at numerous positions, lets hope they get this one right this season.

Walter Payton lives on!!!

by monsterman34 on Feb 25, 2010 8:58 PM CST reply actions  

Not for a Cover 2

Sharper had a miserable last couple of years in Minnesota for the same reason. He doesn’t like the Cover 2 and doesn’t strive in the Cover 2.

Antrel Rolle is going to be the “best” Free Safety to hit the market this year. Atogwe may not get tagged/tendered but Rolle might even be better than Atogwe at this point. Clark out of Pitt is decent but is a much better thumper than coverage defender so he may be way out of his league in a Cover 2, Free Safety spot.

If we don’t sign Rolle, Atogwe or convert a corner you can look at “tweener” Safety/Corner prospects like Myron Lewis (Vandy, 4th-5th round) or Akwasi Owusu-Ansah (Indiana PA, 3rd-4th round) or you can go for a “pure” Free Safety like Robert Johnson (Utah, 5th-6th) or Kurt Coleman (4th-5th).

You can usually draft a Corner and convert him to a Free Safety as long as he has some specific qualities: Good field vision and solid tackling technique. He can be a “slower” corner and still be fine as a Free Safety as long as he reads the field well and can bring guys down solo. a Corner’s ball skills and range, even for a 4.5-4.59 Corner are plenty good enough for the Free Safety spot.

Just my thoughts anyway.

by eldilar on Feb 26, 2010 12:24 PM CST up reply actions  

I would be stoked if we got Rolle.

When it comes to Sharper, I still think he would have been way better than who we had last season even in the cover 2. The Bears have two young talented guys in Afalava and Payne, but neither of them were ready to start at safety last season. A little help and direction from a guy like Rolle is exactly what they need. I just read that they are targeting Rolle if Arizona cuts him next week, looks like the Cowboys are as well. If we were to get both Rolle and Julius Peppers, I could see our defense being mean next season. I just hope they spend the money that is needed to get one, the other, or both.

Walter Payton lives on!!!

by monsterman34 on Feb 26, 2010 7:52 PM CST up reply actions  

drool

"Hey, the offensive linemen are the biggest guys on the field, they're bigger than everybody else, and that's what make them the biggest guys on the field." -Madden

by BearNecessities on Feb 26, 2010 3:20 AM CST up reply actions  

what about Bethea???

He looked great down the stretch this year. He is a restricted FA for the colts…I havent heard whether or not they plan to resign him.

Taylor Mays is an animal. Would love to see him a bear

by djhutchins on Feb 25, 2010 11:05 PM CST reply actions  

The Bears Biggest Offseason Need...

Isn’t even up for debate: It’s a defensive end. Period. Our entire cover two scheme is predicated on a pass rush generated by defensive ends and we aren’t getting that anymore. Because Tommie Harris can not be relied upon to tie up two interior linemen anymore our mediocre rushing ends (Brown/Ogun/Anderson) have simply not been able to reach the QB. This means that opposing offenses have consistently had ample time to pick apart our zone defense. I don’t care if you had frickin Rod Woodson or Ronnie Lott back there at FS, we’d still be giving up 3rd and longs consistently. We MUST have a pass rush.

Now, is the DE need best addressed in the draft? No. The DE need is best addressed by going out and getting the best frickin pass rusher available. And this year, the best guy available in free agency happens to be one of the best in the entire league. You can tell me that he’ll be over paid and you call tell me that Kampan has more heart but I don’t give a crap. I want the best guy available and I don’t care if we have to pay twice as much for him than we would for Kampan.

As for Kampan: Why would you take a risk on this guy who just blew out his knee and may be back for pre-season and you have no idea in what condition he’ll be back in? You already have one starter on the d-line who is only a shadow of his former self due to knee issues. On the other hand, you have a guy who is basically the same age and has had twice the production in the same amount of years in the league.

To me, it’s simple: You do everything you possible can to go get Julius Peppers in a Bears uniform as soon as March 5 rolls around.

Once that deal is done, you can look at your draft board and take the BPA at FS or OL when our first pick comes around on day three of the draft.

by The Kaiser on Feb 26, 2010 7:22 AM CST reply actions  

Nice post i got some rebuddle

Kampan did tear his knee correct. He has never been associated with being a player that takes plays off. Even back when he was only getting 6-7 sacks a year people knew that this guy worked his ass off and gave it his all. Other than playing for those people from wisconsin he is a great talent. His work ethic has chicago written all over and can you imagine him laying out rodgers twice a year?

Peppers- ABSOLUTE BEAST. no other way to say it having him on this team would revive the pass rush and unleash the animal that is Brian Urlacher. We all know he is someone who takes playsoff and no one knows if he will show up after his big day. Honestly i dont know if the bears would fork over that kind of cash.

Kampan would also come cheaper, and allow us to also sign Antrell Rolle if he would like to join us. Lets not sell Kampman short either he has a high motor and can make plays.

by Bear Lovin 21 on Feb 26, 2010 9:16 AM CST up reply actions  

Doesn't do it for me...

Sorry but saying that we should go sign Kampman instead of Peppers simply because he has more heart and doesn’t take as many plays off doesn’t explain why Peppers has twice the production as a pass rusher as Kampman. Add to that the fact that Kampan is a major risk with his knee and Peppers in his his prime and I fail to see a solid argument.

The notion that we should go cheap and sign the injured guy with the big heart so we can save money and then use spread our money around to hire another FA in the secondary really doesn’t wash. Our secondary play will improve more by adding a pass rush without signing another free agent. Rolle is not exactly a “stud” free safety nor are the Colts safeties but they all look great when the QB is being pressured all the time and is forced to make bad passes.

I do agree that Peppers presence will improve Urlachers production and will help tie up the entire defense to some degree.

by The Kaiser on Feb 26, 2010 9:37 AM CST up reply actions  

If we sign peppers the signs of signing an impact player go down severely

Kampan vs Peppers has peppers winning we all know that. but it isnt a landslide.

If i wanted us to go cheap id say sign mark anderson and hes the answer lol

You didnt really get into the fact that peppers may take plays off and these plays could cost us games.

Do i want peppers? Yes because he will revive players on this defense.

Tommie Harris, Brian Urlacher can roam free again and tillman may get more picks his way

by Bear Lovin 21 on Feb 26, 2010 12:28 PM CST up reply actions  

With no cap, they must address all their needs.

DE, FS, OL, RB. Spend the money it takes to address all these areas. Imho… Julius Peppers, Chester Taylor, and Antral Rolle..thats if Rolle is cut next week. I would have included Logan Mankins, but NE will have a restriction on him.

Walter Payton lives on!!!

by monsterman34 on Feb 26, 2010 8:12 PM CST up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Windy City Gridiron is the best independent site on the internet for breaking news, in-depth analysis, and hardcore discussion about the Chicago Bears

Community Guidelines
Start posting about the Bears »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Connect_with_facebook

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Bears2_small
Hester/Knox/Aromashodu: How good can they be this season?
Plato_bust_small
Tales from the SunnySide: Walter Payton's Knees
Plato_bust_small
Memories of the Game

Recent FanPosts

Bears2_small
In Harris and Peppers We Trust
Small
Cowherd says "No Chance" to the Bears and 14 others
Ditkaworld_small
Ditka's Lounge- Carry my bags Rook!
Medium_matt-forte_small
Just another Bears fan (Military Roll Call Edition)
Cash-middle-finger_small
Lions fan here...
Mikemyers_small
What are you looking forward to the most during TC/Pre-Season?
Small
Steve Sabol names the greatest players in NFL history, in his opinion.

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Latest NFL Headlines from SB Nation

SPONSORS

SBNation.com Recent Stories

Photo +2 updates

NFL Training Camps Get Underway: Schedules And News For All 32 Teams

Photo

2010 NFL Preview, Buffalo Bills: Chan Gailey Takes The Reins

Photo +2 updates

2010 NFL Draft Pick Signings: Rolando McClain Is The First Top 10 Draft Pick To Sign

More from SBNation.com >


Managers

Windycity_small Adam T

Photo_small Dane Noble

Editors

19554_711053815498_20723723_41499369_7695586_n_small HoneyBear

22636_276583252155_506182155_3148787_7229724_s_small Kev H

Contributing Writers

Extrusion_profile_new_medium_small Mike Mueller

Tn48-1_small Just Dave

Bears_small Jacob Hayes

Attachment30_small Lester A. Wiltfong Jr.

3961055499_e489f15bb2_o_small David Taylor

Chicago-bears-logo_small Mark Saade