WCG Match-Up Post: Grades and Reviews for Wk 3
All of Bear nation, from the fans, sports talk radio, and even Jay Cutler himself is having doubts about this offense. Usually in year 2 of offensive schemes, players are supposed to have a better understanding of the scheme and execute properly. For the 2nd consecutive week, Mike Martz and his offense has shown us that they still have a ways to go. I'm not ready to fully give up on Martz's system, but it's clear that some adjustments need to be made in order to save this season.
Mike Martz Play-calling Grade C-
Martz's play-calling wasn't a complete failure as the Bears got down early and the Packers were keyed in on stopping Matt Forte on the ground. What he could have done was substitute the run for dump offs and short routes. I never understood his pleasure for the Wildcat especially with no one back there that's even a threat to put the ball in the air. That's a play that needs to be scratched out the playbook because all it does is gets all 11 defenders keying in on the run. Martz has been in the line of fire today and his system is being question to if its suits Jay Cutler and the rest of the offensive players. I don't question his system, but more his play calling and personnel needs for the system.
Pass Protection and Run Blocking Grades B- and F
I thought the offensive line and the RB's did a good job in pass protection. Forte neutralized Charles Woodson corner blitzes and Frank Omiyale surprising did an admirable job on Clay Matthews. Chris Williams might have had his worst game so far this season whiffing on blocks when he was pulling on the outside allowing Forte to get stuffed by Matthews. Although Omiyale had a good job pass protecting, the false starts at home were completely unacceptable. Run Blocking was beyond putrid as the Packers defensive front bullied the Bears O-line on the ground until Martz gave up. So far this season the Bears have not proven they can run the football on just about any defensive front.
Wide Receivers Grades D+
Johnny Knox and Dane Sanzenbacher keeps this grade from being an F. Knox did some good things out there making plays on the ball, and keeping the defender from making a play on the ball by using his body. In my opinion, it is clear to me that Knox is the better receiver at this point than Roy Williams who before Sanzenbacher's TD, dropped a catchable slant pass. He also had a very hard time gaining separation from Tramon Williams throughout the game. Haven't completely given up on Roy, but the leash is shorter. Sanzenbacher played well Sunday and continues to impress me with his awareness on the field despite only being in the league for a couple months. Hester despite the double move on Woodson and a catch in space for big yardage was quiet throughout the day. The Bears should flirt with the idea of putting Bennett as the starting flanker with Dane in the slot and Hester coming in on some plays.
Passing Game/ Running game Grade C- and Grade INC
The two interceptions were completely on Jay. The 1st one he didn't put the ball on the sideline which gave Morgan Burnett (damn he's a good player) the opportunity to make a play on the ball which he did. The other INT just sailed on Jay which was an easy INT for Burnett. It simply wasn't Jay best day throwing the football and you can see out there that he doesn't trust his receivers or protection. Don't know if I can give Forte a grade simply because Martz didn't call his number enough for him to warrant one from me.
33 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Wait, was the play-calling responsible for the penalties, the dropped passes, and the interceptions?
Because of Hester’s false-start, the wild-cat wasn’t even an official play.
The Packers number one goal was to stop Forte. Despite that focus, Martz still was able to get the ball to him in space. If anyone else, besides Forte, had decided to show up, maybe Martz could have called some running plays.
The offense scored 17 points with little help from special teams or the defense (they started one drive in GB territory), without having any talent on the offensive line, at the wide receiver position, and a bad game by the quarterback. I think Martz’s playcalling was the best part of the offense in that game.
Personally D-
At Best.
Cacti are prickly.
by crackedcactus on Sep 27, 2011 4:56 PM CDT via iPhone app up reply actions
Its late and I will comment more tomorrow but
I disagree with the assumption that this team played differently the first week compared to the last two. I think that Atlanta is just a very overrated team. The last two games just further reinforced the notion that this team is an average one at best. We still have the same problems. WRs and O-Line has been a problem for YEARS. I have no clue how Angelo keeps his job.
Angelo is certainly the cancer.
The reason they don’t fire him is that they don’t want to pay him to walk. Whether we win or lose doesn’t change the bottom line, and the McCaskeys are all about the Benjamins. He’s pooched us ever since he came here. Who did he draft? Briggs. Forte. Big deal.
I tend to agree...
about the play calling overall. The called plays should probably have worked better, but they were simply executed badly by mediocre talent. I’d like to see a better overall strategic game plan from Martz as he tends to still be “working out” what he wants to do during the game rather than before it. The offense simply lacks a purpose and direction in general.
Tice and Drake a have more to atone for that anyone IMO. The fundamentals of their players are so bad that no amount of game planning can work well. The pass protection was aided by the fact that the Packers were playing more coverage and the run blocking (a supposed strength) is a joke. The WRs are just fundamentally unsound and have trouble catching the ball, which is kinda a big deal. Knox caught less than 50% of the passes thrown his way, that sucks. The Bears problems on offense, as I’ve said all season, is that they cannot do the simple basics very well. No scheming can fix that. Granted some of the problems are talent related, but most of this is just poor technique.
"There's a fine line between stupid, and clever!"
Isn't anyone having doubts about Jay Cutler?
Aside from any issues people may have with the coaches/ recivers, whatever, there is an elephant in the room. Jay Cutler isn’t very good.
When he has little time to throw he makes bad decisions. When he has all day, he’s inaccurate. When do the excuses stop? He’s a good quarterback, not a great one. The training wheels are off, this is who Jay is.
Pretend you’re not a Bears fan just for a minute. Look back at his career. Take a deep breath. Now assess him internally. See?
If you were facing an avalanche with only a wall of Swiss cheese in front of you
you would be scared too. Like Mr. Blanton pointed out,
he doesn’t trust his receivers or protection
He just needs to calm down, and one way for that to happen is running the ball or utilizing the screen game.
excellent response
If Cutler and Rogers were switched, I have little doubt people would be gushing about how wonderful Cutler is and wondering if Rogers is a talented underachiever.
I always turn to the sports section first. The sports page records people's accomplishments; the front page has nothing but man's failures.
~Earl Warren
by lookingdeadred on Sep 27, 2011 8:01 AM CDT up reply actions
The Packers #4 receiver
would be the Bears #1
Whenever Mike Ditka boards an aircraft, it changes its call sign to Bear Force One.
by Lester A. Wiltfong Jr. on Sep 27, 2011 8:22 AM CDT up reply actions
Didn't we go through this scenario?
Five foot three seems to thrive on his misery...
by awfullyquiet on Sep 27, 2011 4:08 PM CDT up reply actions
No
because “some” actually look at the pieces of crap Angelo put around him…or didnt put around him. Aaron Rodgers was at a perfect position to be as good as he is, if he started his career off as a bear he would suck here. THATS how bad it is…Hell Brady and Manning wouldn’t last the season with the crap we have on offense
We Are Guardian Force...READ IT!...BAM!!!
I hate to admit it.
I have a lot of respect for what Ted Thompson did up north.
Weekend contributor and official editorial lackey/waitstaff at Windy City Gridiron
If a people-avoiding gaming hermit is on Twitter, I should be too. Follow me!
by Steven Schweickert on Sep 27, 2011 8:55 AM CDT up reply actions
Its okay to admit that GB
Is a very successful and extremely well run organization. There is a reason they have had so much success.
Green Bay
Green Bay is a good organzation. Chicago should be. I don’t think that we can draft any player right now and wait 3-4 years like GB did with #12. I don’t think there is a good enough judge of talent in the GM’s office for us to even think about it. We need to assess our players physical and mental skills and put an offense in place all of the players are capable of being successful in.
Plus the fact that Jay's in his third offensive system in six years
All the great QBs – Brady, Manning, even ol’ jerkface Rivers – have been marinating in the same system for years in order to get to a comfort level that makes them automatic. Rodgers had been studying the same playbook for three years before he got to start, and even when he first started he looked like a “talented underachiever.” Now look at Rodgers.
Does Cutler have flaws in his game? Of course. But it’s hard to overcome those flaws when you’re in a complex system with mediocre talent and you’re on your back all the time.
by NorthSideBearsFan on Sep 27, 2011 9:16 AM CDT up reply actions
Very true! The best QB's in the league are surrounded with decent to great talent in order to maximize their potential/skill. Cutler has been giving manure and is expected to turn it into gold.
Look Cutler hasn’t proved to be worth what was given up for him but I for one do NOT regret the trade. The ultimate failure of the offense is on Jerry Angelo. He traded for a Ferrari but gave it a Pinto’s engine. He has refused to do anything about the oline and has more importantly refused to give Jay that weapon that strikes fear into a defenses heart. Yes Jay isn’t perfect and yes he was inaccurate most of the time on Sunday but when he was on and driving the guys he’s expecting to help him put points on the board screwed him royally with penalties and drops.
It’s very easy to be frustrated at Cutler but ultimately he’s only partly responsible for the situation here in Chicago and that is not being a homer that’s seeing the situation for what it really is. None of the top QB’s in the league have had the same amount of turnover in system and crap talent as Cutler has had. People are tired of hearing excuses I get it. But the shouldn’t be tired of hearing the truth either.
by frenchbears113 on Sep 27, 2011 9:39 AM CDT up reply actions
Cutler missed throws
that at least half the QBs in the league would have made. He had a bad day.
Often Wrong, Never In Doubt.
he did...
he also had over 300 yards passing, and his receivers had a few drops…
Whenever Mike Ditka boards an aircraft, it changes its call sign to Bear Force One.
by Lester A. Wiltfong Jr. on Sep 27, 2011 1:08 PM CDT up reply actions
Remember what Angelo said after the 08 season. "It all starts with the QB".
Seems Angelo took that to heart and ignored putting decent talent around him.
by Dominique Blanton on Sep 27, 2011 2:05 PM CDT up reply actions
Angelo thinks QB's are like Swiss Army Knives: They're SUPPOSED to do everything including pass protection, run blocking AND catching TD's. Why else would he have blatantly ignored OL and WR?
by frenchbears113 on Sep 27, 2011 3:15 PM CDT up reply actions
Angelo believes that good QBs make good receivers. They don't.
He also believes that the key to good offensive lines is familiarity and gelling. True, but you need talent before that becomes possible. Angelo is wrong about his basic beliefs and he should be tarred and feathered and hung from the nearest tree.
QB
I personnaly like Jay Cutler and hope he has a long succussful and healthy career in Chicago. I think Angelo should be locked in his room on draft day until round 4.He has been a continual failure with early round draft picks, both drafting and trading! Gabe Carimi may be his best 1st rounder, jury will be out for a few years.
Forte and Bennett were great picks
by Dominique Blanton on Sep 27, 2011 9:14 PM CDT up reply actions
Out of 70+ picks, yeah. Blind squirrels. Nut-location.
If you are seriously defending Jerry Angelo at this point then … then I don’t know what to say to you. Go back through every draft pick he’s made. There’s a start.
Why oh why
does Knox get a pass for a ball he saw coming bouncing off his facemask?
????
“Johnny Knox and Dane Sanzenbacher keeps this grade from being an F.”
- Do you use a reverse grading system where F means ‘good’? Johnny Knox blows as a receiver. Can’t spell separation never mind get any, or adjust his routes, or do any of the things a good receiver needs to do. Hester and Knox are return men, nothing more.
“…it is clear to me that Knox is the better receiver at this point than Roy Williams …”
You and you alone, Mr. Wonder.
And what makes you think
Droppapatmus Williams is any better?
He doesn’t have speed or hands, and rarely uses his size to the able to the ball.
Cacti are prickly.
by crackedcactus on Sep 28, 2011 10:52 AM CDT up reply actions

by 























