2012 Chicago Bears Roster Turnover: Tackle
Can you name the Bears last Pro Bowl offensive tackle?* It's been a while, and with two 1st round draft picks spent on the position in the last four years you'd have thought, at the very least, that the position would have been stabilized by now.
In this ongoing series we'll take a position by position look at the Chicago Bears roster and speculate on who stays, who goes, and some potential moves. With the help of Pro Football Focus we'll be able to bring you their unique perspective by utilizing their Premium Content. We've already looked at the centers and guards, so this post will finish off the offensive line.
Since I believe the future of Lance Louis is at guard, even though most of his 2011 reps were at right tackle, I put him in with the guards. For a look at Louis click the link above.
J'Marcus Webb - Signed through 2013 - I really hope that with a full off season to work at left tackle that Webb can become the player Mike Tice believes he can. I've seen nothing but inconsistency from Webb at LT in 2011 and when he was a RT in 2010. There's been flashes of brilliance, but also sloppy technique. I'm sure he'll be around next season, but I hope he'll have some competition for the left side. Either via a draft pick, free agency, or someone on the roster.
Pro Football Focus had Webb graded right behind former Pro Bowler Ryan Clady at #67. His -24.7 was helped by his o-line leading 14 penalties. His 12 sacks given up were 2nd worst among all linemen, but his 29 QB pressures wasn't as bad, considering there were 19 tackles that had more.
Gabe Carimi - Signed through 2014 - If Carimi can play like a first round talent it will go a long way in solidifying the line. I'd be OK if they let him work on the left side, but that's unlikely. In Carimi's brief time, 100 offensive snaps, he had a neutral grade of -0.3 (PFF considers grades that close to zero neutral). They had him with a rough start in week 1 at -1.9, but a good bounce back game in week 2 with a +1.6. Hopefully that was a trend that continues.
Frank Omiyale - Signed through 2012 - Omiyale is due $1.6 million this season and a quarter million dollar workout bonus. I don't think he'll see any of that cash. I think we unfairly bash him sometimes, as much of the pressure he gave up was due to the stubbornness of Mike Martz, leaving Omiyale on an island is dumb. In week 16 against the Packers he played 50 snaps at right tackle and he had a +1.3 grade. But with that being said, I think he may be a cap casualty. PFF had him at an overall -11.8 for his time at tackle.
Levi Horn - Terms undisclosed - Horn spent some time on the active roster last year, but he's never had any in game reps. He may be around next year, but his roster spot is by no means safe.
Perry Dorrestein - Terms undisclosed - The rookie from Michigan ended the season on the practice squad, and he may be around this off season to try and do it again.
2012 OUTLOOK - As I previously said, I think Webb needs some competition, and I'd be fine if the Bears drafted a tackle in the first few rounds. Looking at the potential free agents, Buffalo's Demetrius Bell, who only played 7 games due to injury was graded at #17 with a +6.8. Also at #17 was Jared Gaither who only played 5 games (he was a free agent most of the year) for the Chargers. I've seen Jeff Backus brought up in our threads and he was graded at -2.0 good for #32.
* The last Pro Bowl offensive tackle for the Bears was James "Big Cat" Williams in 2001.
Here's the 2012 Chicago Bears Roster Turnover series so far;
Quarterback
Running Back
Tight End
Wide Receiver
And center and guard are linked up there in paragraph number 2.
33 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
JaMarcus Webb- signed through 3013
You’d think for a cyborg he’d be a better blocker.
by TJ Shouse on Feb 14, 2012 11:07 AM CST via Android app reply actions
Yeah, I like that one.
No Offense Lester, I like your roster turnover posts but we all know that its hit or miss with this o-line. One week they actually look good. Then the next bad. and so on and so forth.
Wouldnt it be funny if we had another DE with the last name Salters!
Im so used to typing offense (offence)
Wouldnt it be funny if we had another DE with the last name Salters!
Disagree. I see Webb be consistently bad- with lots of his badness being covered up by Jay's feet and arm or TE's helping out.
Seriously, he is really bad, you guys.
"With all due respect, and I mean with ALL due respect...that idea ain't worth a velvet paintin' of a whale and a dolphin gettin' it on."
by CurtisEnisFan on Feb 14, 2012 4:14 PM CST up reply actions
but....
At least he’s not Gate 68 bad.
Cacti are prickly.
by crackedcactus on Feb 14, 2012 9:59 PM CST up reply actions
I guess there aren't many supporters of him left
He’s younger than Ryan Tannehill, the same age as Coby Fleener, and he’d be the biggest OT prospect in this draft. Young guys are supposed to have growing pains … young guys from West Texas A&M are definitely supposed to have growing pains.
Good points all...
…I just don’t want him as my starting LT. He’s cheap enough and young enough and has enough of the physical tools/possible upside that make him valuable… as a backup/swing OT.
I personally don’t think he’ll develop into a starting LT by the time his rookie contract is done (or maybe ever). I think he has value as a backup because right now he’s just not good. But at least he’s not the ol’ Omiyale trainwreck bad.
I also think he has more of a skillset for RT then LT.
wrt Webb
What was his run blocking grade from PFF? Did he have any positive graded games? positive graded pass blocking games?
Thanks and keep up the great work Lester.
He only had 2 negative run block graded games on the year 1 positive, and the rest neutral.
Overall he had 9 negative games (5 really bad ones) 3 positive games and 4 neutral
When Mike Ditka calculates pi it's decimal representation ends. | @wiltfongjr
by Lester A. Wiltfong Jr. on Feb 15, 2012 9:16 AM CST up reply actions
Our last Pro Bowl tackle
Was also converted from the DL.
Above all; keep 'em guessing, never let them lose their sense of confusion.
I think he knew that he was just stating a little-known fact
by frenchbears113 on Feb 14, 2012 12:12 PM CST up reply actions
or if you read all the way down the post... :/
When Mike Ditka calculates pi it's decimal representation ends. | @wiltfongjr
by Lester A. Wiltfong Jr. on Feb 14, 2012 12:38 PM CST up reply actions
One of us forgot the sarcasm font!
When Mike Ditka calculates pi it's decimal representation ends. | @wiltfongjr
by Lester A. Wiltfong Jr. on Feb 14, 2012 12:49 PM CST up reply actions
I've not been a big fan of PFF...
and their grading of the o-line. For their system to rank Webb ranked anywhere near Clady tells me all I need to know about their system. Nonetheless, I do think Webb is a serviceable OT, but I do not see him being much more than a swing tackle in his best years. Contrary to your hope that he gets better with more reps, I actually think he’ll be better with less reps. If the Bears can keep him as a back-up/swing tackle/spot starter and get a legitimate, technically sound (if not physically gifted) LT, Webb should be very good in limited duty and provide the kind of depth that I see guys like Louis and Garza being. If the Bears can get some better front-line talent on the O- and D-lines, they have some great depth in many of their current starters.
There's a fine line between stupid...and clever!
To be fair, Clady wasn't that good this year
by frenchbears113 on Feb 14, 2012 12:13 PM CST up reply actions
your right about that, he fell off big time.
Wouldnt it be funny if we had another DE with the last name Salters!
No question about it...
yet still, Webb is nowhere near as good. Perhaps Clady had some undisclosed injury issues…or his love of pagan festivals prompted him to shun the angelic Tebow.
There's a fine line between stupid...and clever!
Nah....he was just confused about what to do
without a QB taking the snaps.
Cacti are prickly.
by crackedcactus on Feb 14, 2012 10:00 PM CST up reply actions
Clady's pass block was much better than Webb's
but his run blocking rated among the league’s worst.
I'm with you on PFF's linemen ranking.
But I disagree with you in pretty much every other way.
He’s not physically overmatched in any way, has the physical toolset, the lateral agility, the step and positive strength, the rest of the work to make him into a good tackle is technique and reaction work, both of which I think come with time. I think he’ll make himself into a fine tackle in the future with a bit more seasoning. His lapses in play are something I think will be reduced in time.
Five foot three seems to thrive on his misery...
by awfullyquiet on Feb 15, 2012 12:44 PM CST up reply actions
I agree that he's physically...
able to do the basics of the LT position, but his technique and movement is slow and bad. Speed rushers fly by him without much problem and power rushers push him backward without much effort. His run blocking is fairly good which says he has the physical strength and size to be a good pass blocker, but his footwork and decision making is just awful. He lunges too often at speed/wide-9 rushers getting off balance and taking himself out of position to recover and force a wide angle. He is also not able to hold his point against bull rushes, again because of technique and foot placement, not strength. That speaks to his ability to do the mental parts of the game, which do not seem to be improving. I would be happy to see Webb get better, I just do not believe he can do the job. I’d rather the Bears take their chances with the interior line and get a competent LT even if the upside is only a year or two of quality LT play. Webb, IMO, has plateaued in his development and his mediocrity is more of a liability than it would be at other positions. We all know what barely good enough does at key positions (QB, DE, WR), it’s time to get it right for a change.
There's a fine line between stupid...and clever!
Put Webb back at guard along with Louis
and dump Chris Williams. Get a badass LT at FA and all will be well.
Has Webb ever played guard?
I think he’s too long to be effective inside
When Mike Ditka calculates pi it's decimal representation ends. | @wiltfongjr
by Lester A. Wiltfong Jr. on Feb 15, 2012 10:14 AM CST up reply actions
Agreed.
Five foot three seems to thrive on his misery...
by awfullyquiet on Feb 15, 2012 12:44 PM CST up reply actions

by 






















