WCG Mock Draft- Carolina Panthers

by Adam T on Apr 3, 2008 7:33 AM CDT in News Comment 10 comments

CURRENT SELECTION
	Jeff Otah Offensive Tackle Pittsburgh
ANALYSIS: I was originally going to go running back, but DeAngelo Williams is only 3 years deep in the league and has time for improvement. With that being said, Jeff Otah is what the Carolina Panthers need for their offense, he's the tackle that they've needed for a few years now. He's a senior from Pitt and has the experience to be a first years starter for this franchise. He's 6-6 322lbs, which means he's a big man with strength, power and size. It is also to be noted that he's got some long arms, which is great for any big offensive line player. He's versatile and still has time to improve even more as a player as his career goes on. This is a great pick up for the Panthers and I'm suprised no other teams went after him at this point. They will need a good, fresh lineman to protect Delhomme and open up holes for Williams. They'll be able to get away with this pick because they had the chance to improve other positions in the free agency, so now they can draft a tackle. They have gotten Muhammed back on the team who is still familiar with Steve Smith and Jake Delhomme, seems nothing has really changed since he left anyways. They also picked up DJ Hackett to add to their already huge depth at receiver (they have 10 as of now) and have went free agent crazy picking up linebacker Landon Johnson, guard Milford Brown, safety Terrence Holt, guard Keydrick Vincent, and defensive end Tyler Branton. So dont be suprised if they don't help themselves out at tackle since there isnt too much in the draft at this point to help their other need, defensive tackle.
Pick	Team	Player	Drafter	Analysis
1	Miami Dolphins	Jake Long	McRipper	Details
2	St. Louis Rams	Chris Long	Chad	Details
3	Atlanta Falcons	Glenn Dorsey	mas12	Details
4	Oakland Raiders	Vernon Gholston	Doctor Chicago	Details
5	Kansas City Chiefs	Sedrick Ellis	whitebearsox23	Details
6	NY Jets	Darren McFadden	DaNate23	Details
7	New England Patriots	Leodis McKelvin	tyger1147	Details
8	Baltimore Ravens	Matt Ryan	McRipper	Details
9	Cinncinati Bengals	Keith Rivers	tomas21	Details
10	New Orleans Saints	Mike Jenkins	sirus19x	Details
11	Buffalo Bills	Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie	Chad	Details
12	Denver Broncos	Ryan Clady	Arctic Bronco	Details
13	Carolina Panthers	Jeff Otah	DaNate23	Details

See a list of the mock draft participants

The Chicago Bears(tyger1147) are on the clock...

0 recs | Comment 10 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

draft picks

1 more till the bears WHOO HOO!

by SuperBowlXX on Apr 3, 2008 8:24 AM CDT reply actions 0 recs

I'm a little surprised with this one

I thought Chris Williams would go before Otah, though I have seen Otah on some mocks go way high.

I am going to wait until I have the Bears pick in hand, but this draft pretty much is dictating the direction we should go.

by Adam T on Apr 3, 2008 8:33 AM CDT reply actions 0 recs

Yeah

I think the general consensus is that Otah is #4 in the top 4 group of o-linemen. I personally like Williams much better than Otah. But you never know.

by Doctor Chicago on Apr 3, 2008 9:11 AM CDT up reply actions 0 recs

One could argue that is the area of least need for the Panthers. They just resigned Travelle Wharton to a long deal, and tagged Jordan Gross with the intention of reupping him as well. You could argue that they are going to let Gross go after this year because they don't want to spend that much mine on the line, but then why would they spend a first on another tackle?

And since when have the Panthers needed a tackle for a few years?

Did you just pick this out of a hat?

by tomas21 on Apr 3, 2008 3:41 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs

seriously you need to chill out

you keep going on boards and indicting other peoples opinions, jeff otah is huge, that is reason enough for him to go higher than chris williams.

Oh and please dont insult people's grammar and spelling and call them ignorant, if you are gonna do the same thing. "mine"

-leopoldjones

by leopoldjones on Apr 3, 2008 4:17 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs

Did

you read what I wrote? My criticism is not of Otah before Williams, it's that the Panthers need an OT less than just about any team in the league.

Everyone makes an occaisional typo. I criticised when someone had about 6 grammar errors in a 3 sentence period.

by tomas21 on Apr 3, 2008 6:20 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs

I'm pretty sure

The Gross didn't sign long term. They could be looking for his replacement.

by Chad on Apr 3, 2008 11:55 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs

seriously

you need to stop critisizing, he goes before williams on alot of mock drafts and u go on their roster and tell me what they need more than a tackle?

by DaNate23 on Apr 4, 2008 12:16 AM CDT up reply actions 0 recs

ya'll

argure like your married.lmao

by SuperBowlXX on Apr 4, 2008 5:02 AM CDT up reply actions 0 recs

Again,

the criticism is not that Atoah went before Williams, it's that OT is not a need for the Panthers, at least not until late in the draft for depth.

Of the top of my head, I would say QB (since Delhomme has struggled and been hurt, and Matt Moore didn't look good), WR (since they've gotten nothing out of Jarrett so far and Moose is not good), DT (they lost Jenkins), DE (to play across from Peppers) are all FAR greater needs than OT for them. They have two very good offensive tackles, why would they draft another in the first round? That would be like the Bears taking a TE in the first round.

You can be upset at me if you want for pointing it out, but the fact is you didn't look at what the team needed when you made the pick. It's like you looked at it like "who would the Bears take if they picked here?" There is no point in doing a mock draft like this if people don't take a few minutes to look at what the team they are drafting for might need. Otherwise you might as well just do the draft alphabetically, it would be just as randomly inaccurate as picks like this.

by tomas21 on Apr 5, 2008 1:25 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs